Simon Wolfe of Capsule Computers writes:
"Total Drama Island is rife with stereotypical teenage archetypes and for a show about those teenagers being on a reality game show, that’s just about right. The show itself parodying reality game shows adds that bit of extra humor required to make for an interesting series. Making flash games for the show wouldn’t seem that difficult to pull off either as parodying reality game shows means that a game can simply be based off of almost any of the challenges featured in the series. Better yet as the cast of contestants numbers more than 20, featuring different the best fit wouldn’t be too hard either. Though it really comes down to how well the challenge can translate and how fun it actual is, as to whether this is a game to play or pass on."