Quantcast
570°
Submitted by dirigiblebill 305d ago | opinion piece

Six games everybody hated that sold millions anyway

OXM's Edwin writes: "Everybody knows that online reaction and review scores don't necessarily correspond to game sales, but when you're hitting F5 half your life, it can be easy to forget.

There's a whole ecosystem of wallet-armed brains beyond the spiky fortifications of gaming proper, brains that often base their judgements on marketing materials and brand recognition alone. Don't believe us? Glance down this list of games that should have sold bugger-all, yet somehow didn't." (PC, PS3, Resident Evil 5, Xbox 360)

« 1 2 »
Them_Bones  +   305d ago
On the internet it's cool to hate on popular things, so pretty much anything that sells millions has haters.
dirigiblebill  +   305d ago
Truth.
MaxXAttaxX  +   304d ago
On the internet it's also cool to generalize and assume that everyone thinks it's cool to hate on popular things.

So that's not always the case.

It's the same thing with movies. Many times you have pretty bad movies with terrible reviews and they're at the top of the box office.
skyrim  +   304d ago
Double truth
KingME  +   304d ago
Don't agree with COD being on the list. All the others I did pass on.
thats_just_prime  +   304d ago
cod and star wars are just flame bait. Tons of people liked both.
Gaming101  +   304d ago
This should be titled "6 games I personally hate that sold well anyway". Those games don't sell well because people hate them, it's because they actually enjoy playing them dummy - the author has a screw loose. just because you hate fitness games or call of duty doesn't mean no one else in the world does. Oh wait, he writes for official xbox magazine, of course he has a screw loose.

Of course regarding transformers, that game actually was crap.
#1.1.5 (Edited 304d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report
KumaKreations  +   305d ago
Very true. The most money comes from people that bash stuff.
master_beta   305d ago | Spam
WeskerChildReborned  +   304d ago
Yep, anything that is mainstream basically gets hate.
darkride66  +   304d ago
You hit the nail right on the head. When something becomes popular it doesn't matter if it's a movie, videogame, tv show, band, you name it - suddenly it'll garner hate for absolutely no reason. GTA4 was a masterpiece and sold very well yet there's the haters, hating all over it. Bioware used to be everyone's favourite and now it doesn't matter what they do, people want to dump all over them. Forget about the Mass Effect 3 ending thing, people were lining up to hate that game before it ever released. Gran Turismo was nitpicked to death months before it even came out, Diablo 3 had people up in arms because they didn't like the colors used, and despite being a solid game people bash it at every opportunity. MW3 is a strong game overall, yet you'd think based on the forums that Activision took a dump on your console.

If it's popular, you can bet the internet will hate it, regardless of the actual quality of said product.
Imalwaysright  +   304d ago
"regardless of the actual quality of said product." And who are you to set the standard of quality of any product? We are NOT mindless drones and each of us has the right to have an opinion!

GTA4 was boring to me. It felt like a shore to finish it. I didnt like the story, characters and the dark look of the city. Everything felt depressing in a franchise where to me was about mindless fun, The Radio's stations were crap but i was already expecting it since today music is crap anyway. Taking variety and RPG elements from previous installments didnt help either.

Bioware is making more and more streamlined games. Their games arent as complex and deep has some of their older franchises. Its naive to think that every Bioware fan is happy about it. DA2 was horrible and ME3 has been debated to hell and there is no point in keep arguing about it.

GT is in my opinion a great game but it had MANY flaws at launch. Since then PD has been working to improve their game and they stand as one of my most respected devs in the industry. Still the flaws were there and people had every right to have a negative view towards them and criticize them.

As soon as Blizzard announced that we had always to be online i knew that i wouldnt waste my time or money with D3.

I never played a single CoD game so naturally i wont comment on it.

Now i dare you to tell me that i shouldnt feel this way about these games.
#1.4.2 (Edited 304d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(5) | Report
otherZinc  +   304d ago
Maybe the author is stupid: A friggin series sold MILLIONS! COD, hate it all you want you inter-net know it alls, the game is good.

I dont prefer it but its a very good game. You dont get repeat sales by Marketing you Idiots!
Them_Bones  +   304d ago
When CoD4 first came out it was a f*cking masterpiece back in 2007, so good that people told their friends and word spread really quick, activision thought 'looks like we have a powerhouse franchise in our hands' and then decided to just milk the series refusing to improve anything because they simply didn't need to, the demand was still there.
The series to me has never been bad or anything less that good (although I don't even play the multiplayer but I still know what the story is there) but it's really showing it's age now and that's what most people will hate if for. The developers don't deserve all the money they are getting for such little work in comparison to developers like rockstar.
jimbobwahey  +   304d ago
I still enjoy the COD games and buy them each year. People will say that it's the same game over and over, but they make more improvements than I've seen other developers of shooters manage, and the developers always cram a hell of a lot of content into the COD games as well that make it easily worth the money.

I mean take for example that most multiplayer shooters will ship with about 8 multiplayer maps, COD always gives you 16 by default. Most games have crappy/tacked-on co-op modes as well, but in COD they're fully fleshed out with a huge amount of content and missions. It's things like this that bring me back to COD, because in my opinion at least, they give you so much content and hours of fun for the money that it's hard to pass on.
showtimefolks  +   304d ago
OP get one thing straight

homefront is the main reason THQ is is trouble, they put too much into one game than invested heavily into advertisement only to come out and not sell 10 plus million

i am not into fitness or exercise games but i should be lol. I think if anything gaming has evolved a bit where you can get in shape while playing so not bad. Not sure why anyone would hate on that

Resident evil 5 was a good game but its not resident evil by any means. Watch from everything i have read about RE6 its not looking good. Capcom is trying to please all sides and they will fail at it. Let me ask you a simple thing when this gen began capcom had a lot of talented devs working for them guess what now most of them have either started their ow studios or came to a western publisher. That's what happens when sequels are all a company want to do. There would not a a dead rising game if it wasn't for one of their guys hiding the development till it was 50% done so capcom had to push it out the door.

after THQ capcom is next in line and i don't buy their games new i rather give my money to gamestop buying used than to these greedy bastards with all their on disk dlc

star wars force unleashed was a good game but nothing amazing but since its SW you know it was gonna sell

call of duty is a good series and they make good games no one can deny that its just we have seen it all time for something new and fresh. But sad thing is core gamers make such a small % of the gaming community that we can hate it all we want as long as noobs/casuals keep buying it nothing is gonna stop it. But just like guitar hero the day is coming sooner rather than later when activision won't be able to sell COD as well

tranformers games are ok to good but since its TF you know it will do well
Ravenor  +   304d ago
By Homefront, you must mean uDraw 360/PS3.

It wasn't Homefront entirely, uDraw caused far more harm then Homefront.
Ranma1  +   304d ago
Final Fantasy XIII

didnt deserve the sales it made...the sales which came from brand name alone
Gamer1982  +   304d ago
I loved res 5 the co-op system made it even better. The only haters was those who wanted it to be llike previous games. If you want that your out of luck but games evolve over time its a sad fact some for the better some for the worse. I personally prefer the new feel resident evil. Dislike new FF games though minus 13-2.
gamerben  +   304d ago
Final Fantasy VII = Evidence
OVOXO_Mike  +   304d ago
**Waiting for someone to troll about CoD** waittt for ittt....
Oh_Yeah  +   304d ago
games will sell well just because of a big name -__-
me personally idgaf who makes it or how good the prequal was.
i look at gameplay vids or try demos out before i get a game.
#1.11 (Edited 304d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Farsendor1  +   304d ago
don't hate things just because its popular most of the time if i hate a game its cause i really don't like it or feel that it could have been better.

i liked resident evil 5
i liked forced unleashed 1 and 2
i liked homefront

now cod is a half and half thing for me.

i like the campaign mode but im so tired of multiplayer.

just played a little over 30 mins of mw3 multiplayer.
Jam_sponge  +   305d ago
@Them_Bones

Everybody seems to like Skyrim, Battlefield and Minecraft.
#2 (Edited 305d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(5) | Report | Reply
Them_Bones  +   305d ago
Skyrim and BF3 have got plenty of haters, usually for skyrim it's because of all the glitches and the fact that people can't get over their nostalgia of previous elder scrolls games and appreciate the new one, and for BF3 it's because the game was a downgrade from BC2 in terms of destruction, weapon balancing, server renting etc.
I don't know anything about minecraft so I can't judge it.
Disco Downey  +   305d ago
I dont like Skyrim cos its super repetitive and the combat is a travesty.
dasteru  +   304d ago
Its human nature to bias towards a first experience and never feel like anything newer is as good. Why do you think FFVII is so well regarded. IV, VI and IX were all better games (90% of FF fans who have been around since the start will agree) but all the FF's before it were still a niche to some extent. A large portion of the current FF fanbase started their experience with VII and will therefor always regard it as the best.
Disco Downey  +   305d ago
I dont like any of those three games.
MySwordIsHeavenly  +   304d ago
Read: I don't like video games.
Sargerus  +   304d ago
People hate BF3 because of EA and Origin, hardcore Oblivion fans hate Skyrim because they think Skyrim is too simple, people hate Minecraft because of it's graphics and don't have guns/explosions
gamerben  +   304d ago
I've seen a fair share of minecraft haters, especially on this site :P
NYC_Gamer  +   305d ago
Everybody didn't hate those games just many folks on gaming forums did
spunnups  +   305d ago
I didnt hate RE5, But I can see why others did.
General Shrooms  +   304d ago
the worst RE to date, its about to be trumped though.
Sargerus  +   304d ago
you obviously didn't play RE Survivor or RE Operation Raccon City
StarFox  +   304d ago
you obviously have never played RE Gaiden.
Vandamme21  +   305d ago
RE5 was good..it just wasn't as good as RE4.
master_beta   305d ago | Spam
aDDicteD  +   305d ago
and it was inferior to resident evil 1,2,3, code veronica, 4.
Heavenly King  +   304d ago
For me RE4 is better than the previous games. And RE5 is like RE4 on steroids; in other words the best RE for me is RE5.
blahblah346  +   304d ago
RE5 was awful...nothing like RE4
m-s-8-2  +   305d ago
Zumba Fitness selling as much as it dis makes me want to punch 6 million people in the face.
MySwordIsHeavenly  +   304d ago
Well, it's a tool used to get people into shape. I would say the sales for it are a positive thing.
Soldierone  +   304d ago
Have you ever seen someone attempt to "play" a game like this sitting down? I have seen it.....
#6.1.1 (Edited 304d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report
CLOUD1983  +   305d ago
No1 in the list must be FFXIII it sell well but that was because ppl get it w/o some research first they trust the name & popularity of the series but I'm sure it wont happen again, now every1 knows that SE cant be trusted FF of Squaresoft & SE is 2 completely different things quality-wise.
Capt-FuzzyPants  +   305d ago
Well it wasn't hated by everyone. I still believe it was a good game. Not a legendary game like 6,7,10, or some of the other FFs but it was still a great game. But yeah I expected it to be on the list too because of all the people who still whine about years later.
Hicken  +   304d ago
Agreed. I, for one, loved the game, if I was a little disappointed here or there with some things. But I'm also one of the apparent few FF fans who thinks VII is not the best in the series (I prefer VIII), so me having a different opinion on XIII probably isn't much of a surprise.

I don't think the "hate" for XIII is as widespread as some people(Ranma) would like for it to be, but as you said, it will likely never be considered legendary, like many of the other entries in the franchise.
tigertron  +   305d ago
Anything with COD in it post COD4.
MySwordIsHeavenly  +   304d ago
Um... Why not Modern Warfare 2? That's one of the best single-player campaigns this generation.
tigertron  +   304d ago
Not sure if serious...
SnotyTheRocket  +   304d ago
Uncharted 2 would like to have a word with you.....
Ravenor  +   304d ago
@MySwordIsHeavenly

First you say KZ3 had a FANTASTIC SP, and now MW2 was one of the best SP campaigns of this gen?

Clearly you are a reasonable person and your opinion should be trusted when discussing games. /s
TotalHitman  +   304d ago
MySwordIsHeavenly has a bad taste in games.
torchic  +   305d ago
Modern Warfare 3.

I think that was the first properly bad Call of Duty since, forever.

I'd give it a 5.5/10

many people thought so too, yet it still sold millions
#9 (Edited 305d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
MySwordIsHeavenly  +   304d ago
Call of Duty 3 was the first bad COD. :/ Then, we all had to put up with World at War, Black Ops, and Modern Warfare 3.
Stallion  +   304d ago
COD 3 was one of two bad CODs. World at War was fine, just wasn't as legendary as COD 4 so it was a disappointment, but BLACK OPS!??!? Black Ops was the best one since COD4. Then MW3 sucked.
Soldierone  +   304d ago
COD3 was the reason i wouldn't touch COD4 for the longest time....Then I finally did, and it was better.

World At War wasn't "terrible" but it wasn't good either. The only thing that really hurt it was the fact Activision for some reason decided to let Treyarch stay with WWII when we all wanted modern warfare.
MacDonagh  +   305d ago
Hate is an irrational emotion that clouds one's very reason. I feel nothing at all for the games in the article whatsoever. So if someone sees something that I don't in any of those titles in question; who am I and who are you to say that they are wrong?
#10 (Edited 305d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(5) | Report | Reply
chukamachine  +   305d ago
res5 was awful game, broken controls, awful mechanics.

It was bought on name alone.

6 wouldn't have to do much to be better.
ChunkyLover53  +   305d ago
I own all of the games on that list except for Zumba Fitness. I hate none of them, I think they are all fun and I also think that people assume that a game is hated because their are loud mouthed minority gamers on forums and places like N4G.

Not only do I own almost all of the games listed, but I own COD 2, 3, 4, MW2, MW3, WaW and Black Ops. I own more than a few of those titles on multiple consoles.

IDGAF what people write about a game on some forums, if I like a game or series, I will buy and support it.
numonex360  +   305d ago
Final Fantasy XIII was by far the worst game I have played this generation. Total garbage game, rubbish characters and too linear for an RPG.
kma2k  +   305d ago
Ill admit i never played any of the RE series, stricly because i hated the controls. Last month i forced myself to get over my dislikes about the plant & shot & play RE5 i actually really enjoyed it, now that is comming from someone with no RE background so i have nothing to compare it to. The game in & of itself was enjoyable to me.
IAmLee  +   305d ago
Heres my list: Call Of Duty MW1, Call of Duty WaW. Call Of Duty MW2, Call Of Duty Black Ops, Call of Duty MW3 And Resi 5...
xPhearR3dx  +   305d ago
COD4 and WaW were pretty good IMO.
IAmLee  +   304d ago
any CoD is a bad CoD.
SnotyTheRocket  +   304d ago
Take the time machine, go back to 2007, and play COD4 with out all the "1337 HaX0rZ", and tell me EVERY COD sucks....
Donnywho  +   304d ago
Everybody doesn't hate all of these games. Speak for yourself or use looser words. I think it's time to get back into the game magazines I trusted and used my whole childhood. I am tired of this amateur stuff.

6 Articles everybody hated, now there's an easy list.
Tonester925  +   304d ago
Haters come when Devs change their game or don't.

You get people like for Battlefield "I've played Battelfield since the first one and BF3 sucks because of COD"
smashcrashbash  +   304d ago
Yeah, did you count how many people probably sent back to the store because they realized that it was a bunch of crap? No one ever does. All they count is initial sales. A game could have sold 2 million and 1 million people sent it back to the store or sold it to someone else. So what does that say about the game? That is why I constantly say not to hang on to sales. People continuously boast about how much a game sold but never factor in how many were returned or never played with again.
SITH  +   304d ago
Home front was a beast of a game online. I can not wait for part two.
schlanz  +   304d ago
I love RE5. Gold edition + move + online co-op with my brother is by far the most enjoyable RE experience I've had, survival horror grudges be damned. Really looking forward to 6, even the 3DS game was great.
Roper316  +   304d ago
was really looking forward to RE5 got it, played it and did not like it and have no intentions of buying RE6. I also haven't bought any Capcom game since RE5 after the BS with the pay extra for the Multiplayer which was just locked on the disc that they pulled and have been pulling ever since.
taquito  +   304d ago
Resident Evil 5 was awesome, at least the pc version I played was, looked great, ran beautiful in DX10, loved all the unlockable mercenaries modes

cool boss fights

i don't get it

people complain that the controls didnt suck and it didnt have awful voice acting and terrible fixed cameras like the old ones...lol

look, i love RE in general, I own them all, go back and play Resident Evil 1, 2, 3, Code veronica, the are so lame compared to 4 and 5 in both control and cheese ball dialog, they are great games for their time, but the are not great compared to 4 and 5
Soldierone  +   304d ago
I thought people enjoyed the first Star Wars force Unleashed? It was the second one that everyone hated.....

And Zumba....ugh, this is how crappy games keep getting put out.
spunkee311  +   304d ago
I don't agree with Resident Evil 5. I enjoyed that game a lot. I thought it was great. It definitely was no Resident Evil 1,2 or 4. But still a proper addition to the series. Not bad at all. And all my friends enjoyed it too. I see a lot of people bash it online just cause it's not "scary" enough.
Same with the Call Of Duty series. Online and on internet sites like this one people hate it. But all my friends and I enjoy it and we've spent countless hours having a good time on the Multiplayer and Co-ops. I've gotten used to the fact that this game is going no where and that one will be released per yet. It is what it is. I've only played COD4MW and after. But can't really say I've played a bad one. And now that they know they have such a monstrous franchise, they will do whatever it takes to keep gamers interested and make a overall better game year after year.
spunkee311  +   304d ago
I'm surprised Halo wasn't on the list. A lot of people seem to hate Halo. Especially online. And ESPECIALLY online on COD multiplayer. And also I saw a lot of hate for GTAIV. Which I will never understand. I love that game and it definitely deserved GOTY for everything it brought to the table.
Seraphemz  +   304d ago
MY GOD !!!!! How many LIST articles will you people fall for !!!!! BOYCOTT this crap...seriously.
sofresh412  +   304d ago
Fuck COD haters! I love cod. I don't care how much people talk down to it. It's the smoothest most responsive shooter out.
DivineHand125  +   304d ago
RE5 and COD does not belong on that list
I had allot of fun playing those games and I'm sure the haters for those games are in the minority
segamon  +   304d ago
i wouldn't say everybody, r YOU everybody?
#29 (Edited 304d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
oldfriend86  +   304d ago
RE5 was still fun. I can understand why people hated it compared to REAL Resident Evil games. I found myself spending hours on Mercenary mode. I still had fun and still haven't cashed in on Capcom's crappy DLC practices.

The other stuff I agree with. Zumba; I know all these dancing games may get annoying, but if someone gets off the couch for at least a week, I'm always fine with that. Those fads are short lived, but again, it's better than sitting.

And I think CoD is slowing down the progress of humanity. Players who know nothing of substance and lack of caring for such, is what is ruining the video game industry. I could just hear Capcom saying, "Why make a great game, when the sheep will just buy CoD/Gears of War like games anyway? There's more of them, than hardcore fans. Let's cater to the masses to make more money!"
« 1 2 »

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories

A.MMO Coming: Black Gold Kicks Off Closed Chinese Beta on May 30

8m ago - A new era is about to come! The steam punk style A.MMO masterpiece Black Gold will kick off its C... | PC

Deezer Takes Your Console From Xbox to Jukebox

8m ago - Global music subscription service Deezer today announced another landmark partnership to give mus... | Xbox 360
10°

LoL DGL Winter Leg Coming Soon

8m ago - The League of Legends Do Gaming League Winter Leg is fast approaching and the teams will be getti... | PC
20°

What we want to see | The new Xbox console

9m ago - As the hours countdown to Microsoft’s eagerly-anticipated reveal, we set down just some of the th... | Xbox 720
Ad

Take the N4G Video Game Quiz and Win a PS4

Now - Download our new trivia game for iPhone and iPad and take our official N4G gamer quiz to win a PS4! | Promoted post
30°

Sniper Elite V2 screenshots

9m ago - Take a look at some screenshots from the Wii U version of Sniper Elite V2. | Wii U
Related content from friends