Submitted by DannyP 741d ago | news

The three most important things in a game are “gameplay, gameplay, gameplay” – Ian Livingstone

Gameplay, gameplay and gameplay are the three most important things for a video game to have.

That’s the view of games industry legend and co-author of the Fighting Fantasy series Ian Livingstone OBE who was speaking to The Train2Game Blog at Develop Conference 2012. (Dev, Develop Conference, Ian Livingstone, Industry, Mobile, PC, PS3, Train2Game, Xbox 360)

Hellsvacancy  +   741d ago
I agree, but im gettin older now (almost 29) so i like a mature story to boot
unchartedxplorer  +   741d ago
If you had read the article, he did say 'You've got to create a strong storyline, a great narrative and have a great emotional engagement' Read the article next time.
MmaFan-Qc  +   741d ago
Heavy Rain
Ravenor  +   741d ago

Can always tell a MMA fan.

Nothing about Heavy Rain was emotionally engaging, it was nothing but plot holes and possibly the silliest motive I have ever witnessed in a game.
PoSTedUP  +   741d ago
i feel older (22) and ive always liked realism in my games since i was younger.

gameplay and graphics for me. screw the story let me shoot up a bunch of bad guys for what ever reason then crash and kill myself in a high speed chase for my enjoyment.
ApolloTheBoss  +   741d ago
“But above all, with a game, the gameplay has to be fantastic because people will always buy a game which has great gameplay and poor graphics over something which has great graphics and poor gameplay.”

This man is my hero.
Gorbenshore  +   741d ago
"...because people will always buy a game which has great gameplay and poor graphics over something which has great graphics and poor gameplay.”

There's the problem. That's like saying, people will buy a rock concert ticket but the band won't be playing a single guitar. Graphics are just as important as gameplay; there doesn't have to be any compromises. I don't think 'The Last of Us' would be getting as much attention if it was a side scroller.
#2.1 (Edited 741d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
krisq  +   741d ago
Hayabusa 117  +   741d ago
So true! Sound is completely over rated!
Fishy Fingers  +   741d ago
Ha, an argument many of N4G agrees with when it suits them. Although 90% of discussions centre around graphics.

How many comments in Wii U threads even mention gameplay as opposed to graphics? 1 in 50 maybe. For the masses to suggest they agree gameplay > graphics is laughable, when their actions clearly show otherwise.
Hayabusa 117  +   741d ago
Exactly. Well said.
#5.1 (Edited 741d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
from the beach  +   741d ago
Great, now what is 'gameplay'?
omarzy  +   741d ago
Add gameplay to that important list as well. Anyone who stated gaming this generation already knows this.
Picnic  +   741d ago
Gameplay is essentially all about the things that you control or that control, or can control you, in some way in a game, otherwise it's graphical or audio windowdressing.

However that graphical or audio windowdressing is what elevates what you are doing above being a kind of sport in to being a kind of theatrical entertainment with explicit or implicit messages about the atmosphere / values of the environment that you are in and the nature of yourself and other characters.

If Mr Livingstone wants to make sports games then maybe gameplay, gameplay, gameplay is his 3 most important things. But for gamesmakers trying to attract young adults with their thirst for magical entertainment and education, gameplay is far from the full picture.

Some might say that technically the gameplay of Silent Hill 3 is pedestrian, having to try numerous locked doors and not that many horrifying monsters. But the character, choice of environments, visuals and sound elevate it to much more in your imagination than is actually in the game.
#8 (Edited 741d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
SageHonor  +   741d ago
I say gameplay and story.
goldwyncq  +   741d ago
It's a VideoGAME so obviously it needs good gameplay.
mt  +   741d ago
I would say "Gameplay, Gameplay , Storyline."
Straightupbeastly  +   741d ago
Gameplay, controls and Environment is all that matters. You can have the greatest story ever, but if the game takes place in a cardboard box with horrible charatcer movements it will suck. If you have a shitty story but the game takes place in an awesome environment, smooth controls with lots of cool stuff to do the game will rock.
#12 (Edited 741d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
NeoBasch  +   741d ago
I have to disagree. One of my favorite games of all time Digital Devil Saga 2, doesn't do much to innovate the RPG genre. The gameplay isn't a whole lot of fun when viewed on its own. The battle system and difficulty settings are pretty good, but it'd get old if it wasn't for the amazing storyline.

Seriously, the story was so good that went straight up to the top for me. All that mattered was I felt a genuine bond between myself and Serph, as well as the rest of the party. The gameplay was far more subtle and relied on the story heavily. If a character left the party for example, you truly felt it, even in the gameplay because everything they achieved on the shared mantra grid would be washed away.

It's stuff like that that immerses me into a game. Not a finely tuned FPS like Call of Duty or Halo. If I play a game with a shitty story, it's already lost a significant amount of respect as far as I'm concerned, it can still be good if the gameplay is amazing (it can make up for it and vice versa with story), but it can never be truly great unless it has at the very least a serviceable story or narrative.
#12.1 (Edited 741d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Straightupbeastly  +   741d ago
You just said the gameplay isn't a whole lot of fun. It's fine of you disagree, just saying.

I think my 3 reasons are why Call of Duty just keeps going. It hits those 3 nails on the head year after year. People may start hating the gameplay, but for any newcomer, as all of us once were, they could easily fall in love with it's fast and hectic gameplay if its new to them.
#12.1.1 (Edited 741d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report
NeoBasch  +   741d ago
I disagree. Yes gameplay is important but so is the visual, aural, and writing aesthetics. Its a VIDEO game. It's a part of the visual art medium, as in: movies, TV shows, paintings, architecture, etc... In an interactive experience it all has to come together. Just like a movie brings together visuals, audio, and writing, so to will video games. The only addition is interactivity, which it has to seamlessly weave into the experience.

And gameplay mechanics are dull, by the way. You can give a game interactivity without building entire systems designed for a particular genre. Developers need to stop focusing on genres like FPS, TPS, Strategy, Racing, etc, and instead focus on how to blend these mechanics together seamlessly in a way that "gameplay mechanics" don't feel repetitive after you've killed the 12,113th terrorist.
Gorbenshore  +   741d ago
good gameplay + good graphics > good gameplay + bad graphics

There doesn't have to be any compromises.
Kaos_Vll  +   741d ago
love this guy!

gameplay is THE most important element for me, but sadly others like me are far and few. most just want a pretty game to look at with nothing to do in it.

how you find enjoyment in playing a game because it looks oh so good but plays like a turd is beyond me. how is that fun? swinging at air, horrible animations,but it looks great!

sadly it doesn't matter how powerful next gen is, most devs are going to use it for graphics ala skyrim and let the gameplay suffer.

2 great examples in dev choice: dragon's dogma and skyrim

skyrim's graphics are incredible but plays like shit. huge open world with NOTHING to do but explore. in a game that boasts over hundrends of hours of gameplay you'd think having good gameplay is important, but it's not to them and it's not to the people who praise it. they NEVER praise skyrim for it's gameplay or story, strictly graphics. yet the game wins awards.

on the other hand, take dragon's dogma, GREAT gameplay that drives you to play well after you've completed everything, good but not great graphics and a decent story to boot (once you've completed the game it makes sense) yet it is hated on.

next gen will be more of the same, more power going to the graphics with gameplay taking a backseat. sad

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Titanfall: Frontier’s Edge DLC Is Now Available

37m ago - The second content pack for Titanfall, titled Frontier’s Edge, is now available to download on th... | PC

Interview with Torrin Rettig from Microsoft Studios Discussing Killer Instinct at SDCC 2014

1h ago - New Gamer Nation sat down with Torrin Rettig from Microsoft Studios during this year's San Diego... | Xbox One

Gravia Tactics is a New Tactical RPG On The Scene

2h ago - Julie Morley writes: "All the combat follows a grid and is turn-based in Gravia Tactics. The enti... | PC

All For One - CLG Swaps Entire LoL Roster When Top Lane Is Forced Back To Korea

3h ago - Counter Logic Gaming, a fan-favorite professional League of Legends team, sends all 5 starters ba... | Industry

Start Making Games for the PS4

Now - Want to design the next generation of video games? Start learning game design today. Click for more info on how to get started. | Promoted post

From Uncharted to The Last of Us: An Hour with Emilia Schatz, Part II

3h ago - Max Level: With all the hype surrounding the critically-acclaimed game, I recently sat down with... | PS3