80°
Submitted by -Mezzo- 892d ago | opinion piece

1up - Metacritic Presents Real Problems for the Industry

1up - Relying on average review scores is an issue for everyone. (Industry, Metacritic)

MultiConsoleGamer  +   892d ago
I'm not commenting about the issue of Metacritic as it relates to the gaming industry.

However, IGN just did this same piece just a few days ago. So either 1up.com can't think of their own material, or someone has an agenda against Metacritic.

BTW, I never use Metacritic. I know which reviewers I trust and I stick with them.
Tony-A  +   892d ago
Yeah, seriously, why the sudden backlash against Metacritic? Kinda random.
#1.1 (Edited 892d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
JoySticksFTW  +   892d ago
Tinfoil hats all around, because I immediately thought the same thing. That Metacritic ticked some people off.

Metacritic was like "NO, Microsoft!! I've been found out!! People are noticing me screwing with review averages; leaving out positive reviews and stuff. They're gonna pin all of this on ME!! But I ain't going down alone! I want MORE swag. And a bag of money every damn week now; not monthly! Or I'll spill the beans on what you, ign, 1up, and the rest of our little cabal have been up to! I'll tell the WORLD!! Mwahahah!!11!!"

MS was like "Screw that. Leave Sony alone for the time being, and divert all resources to Metacritic. Show them what it means to cross us."

Disagree all you want, but don't say you didn't think it :)

VGchartz better keep going on with the program before we start seeing why VGchartz is ruining the industry articles.
#1.1.1 (Edited 892d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report
morganfell  +   892d ago
The backlash is coming from the real problem in the game industry - the press.
digitalkid  +   892d ago
There are no reviews I can trust after Dragon Age 2 which had 9.5 from reviewers, and was awful! Not even gametrailers.com which I trusted most.

Users need a place where they can warn other gamers that product is bad and reviewers are just payed by publisher. You can always read what users have to say and make a decision.

Same with COD, Diablo3, and few others..
Hufandpuf  +   892d ago
i don't even go on metacritic.
WeskerChildReborned  +   892d ago
The last time i was on metacritic was the time when i found out the scores were just ridiculous.
sashimi  +   892d ago
You know what else is a real problem for the industry? low quality biased reviews from websites like ign/kotaku/1up and so many more. Some make an article about that too :P I mean they are the ones adding to metacritic..
#3 (Edited 892d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
edonus  +   892d ago
Metacritic is an issue because so many people trust these things and use them like fact. Truth is they are and average of a bunch of unstructured opinions so it really is has the validity of a fortune teller.

The real issue is that reviews themselve are unstructured and to opinion based. A system like that is too easily corrupted. I think.

I have gotten to a point where the only reviews I trust are from consumers on retail websites.
TheTwelve  +   892d ago
I've been using gamerankings.com for years now.
digitalkid  +   892d ago
Seems to me like the only way to tell developers what a crap they're making. =)

My only low scores there are Dragon Age 2 with 5.
jessupj  +   892d ago
Wow, I can't believe 1up think it's ok to be subjective in a review.

I understand there's always going to be some bias in reviews, but the reviewers job is to be objective as possible.

If you disagree, how about we just get all our reviews from pregnant women from now on since you want to know how the reviewer 'feels' about a game instead of critiquing it against set standards.

Gaming journalism wouldn't be such a joke if more outlets adopted a non-bias mindset.
#7 (Edited 892d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Killman  +   892d ago
I go to Metacritic to compare my experience and opinion with others. For a game like MW2, complete opposites. For a game like Terminator Salvation, quite alike. I find that stuff interesting. =|
DivineAssault  +   892d ago
i use metacritic so get everyones review on the same page.. I dont go based on the score tally in it.. I read from other reviewers thats posted on it

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

RIDE: Triumph Speed Triple Trailer

1h ago - Here is Milestone’s Triumph Speed Triple trailer. The Speed Triple has an aggressive presence, an... | PC
30°

Elite 800 Gaming Headphones Review | The Game Scouts

2h ago - Tin Salamunic: It wasn’t too long ago that only two features mattered when purchasing gaming head... | Tech
30°

Boss! Review | Hardcore Gamer

2h ago - Sometimes, a game doesn’t need to be super deep, with nuanced mechanics, a layered storyline and... | PS Vita
30°

Animal Crossing Looks Pretty In This Pixel Art Demake

3h ago - Brazilian pixel artist Midio has imagined Animal Crossing as a 2D pixel art demake as a piece of... | Nintendo DS
Ad

Need Cash? (US Only)

Now - How would it feel to have your money struggles solved by this time tomorrow? We give fast loans from $100-$10,000+, and repayment terms up to 60 mo... | Promoted post
40°

Exclusive: Interview with cyber-terrorist group, Lizard Squad - why they brought down XBL and PSN

3h ago - Infamous self-proclaimed cyber-terrorist group, Lizard Squad, chose December 25, 2014 to take dow... | Industry