Submitted by Aclay 894d ago | news

Chasing Call of Duty was Homefront's folly, says Gearbox boss

Last week, Gamasutra posted an expose on the downfall of Kaos Studios, developer of Homefront, THQ's attempt to enter the military shooter genre.

This week, Gamasutra had a chance to talk to Gearbox president Randy Pitchford, who heads up the Borderlands studio. The conversation turned to bad decision-making at studios and publishers. Asked by Pitchford for an example of a bad situation, Homefront sprang to mind. (Call of Duty, PC, PS3, Randy Pitchford, Xbox 360)

Soldierone  +   894d ago
Chasing Call of Duty was just one of the mistakes....it doesn't take a genius to figure out what was wrong with it.

1 Weak SP that had HUGE promise. It was an interesting concept that never developed. When it was FINALLY going somewhere it ended. It was short.

2 Glitchy online play. Why do games ship broken? I don't care if you can patch it, its an immediate turn off when you pop in the game and its broken for two weeks.....especially when you have a game like COD sitting there.

3 It was TOO generic. I understand shooters going for the COD basics, but this felt way too generic. Like they put it together in a public FPS engine...again it PROMISED a lot, and failed to deliver it entirely....

Overall its just like many (many) other games. If they would take their time and release it when it was ready, and not "when the time is right" then they would have had a running shot....
joab777  +   894d ago
I agree with everything. It's funny because even cod has alot of issues. So, if u r gonna compete with them (which u automatically do in a military Fps genre), u better bring it. And I mean bring it. Big budget, big engine, alot of testing, and alot of content. And the singleplayer better be really good. Because the first game will be a cult classic like borderlands and then u can begin competing with cod. Battlefield has done a brilliant job. I give homegrown credit for it's advertising campaign. They sold alot of copies for an average game. Had it been really good with great support, the follow up would have been huge. That being said, it still could be. The genre isn't yet dead. MoH has the unenviable task of taking on a fresh version of cod this year along with other great games, and I bet it does well despite the fact that the last one was mediocre. But it could have been a rejuvenated ip also. I believe that publishers simply want yo quickly cash in on a phenomenon, but aren't willing to go all in.
Skateboard  +   894d ago
Capcom has a mission to follow the COD crowd.
#1.2 (Edited 894d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
ironcreed  +   894d ago
Chasing COD is many developer's greatest mistake this gen. Spend that money hiring people with great ideas who can innovate. Then do something original that stands out from the pack and will make people turn their head and say, "wow, where did this come from." Leave COD to burn itself out and don't be afraid to take risks. Else stagnation sets in and all the games start to run together and look the same.
Skateboard  +   894d ago
Now this guy knows what he is talking about.
venom06  +   894d ago
THANK GOD FOR BF3!!! thats a great game that doesn't try to chase that garbage franchise... and NO Close Quarters wasn't trying to be CoD ... there were no stupid killstreaks and deathstreaks in Close Quarters..
wicko  +   894d ago
BF3 campaign was definitely chasing CoD - which sucks because I really enjoyed bad company 1 for it's openness.
christheredhead  +   894d ago
DICE is definitely catering to the COD fans, that's a given.
SJPFTW  +   894d ago
nope. Homefront's folly was it was a crappy game. period.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Fate/Stay Night Characters Make Cameos In Divine Gate

6m ago - GungHo Online Entertainment is taking their crossover strategy from Puzzle & Dragons and applying... | iPhone

Hyakka Ryouran Elixir ~Record Of Torenia Revival~ to release on April 9, 2015

6m ago - Kaga Create have announced the release date of the PS Vita game, Hyakka Ryouran Elixir ~Record Of... | PS Vita

Far Cry 4 review | PC Mag

9m ago - Pagan Min is criminally underused, but Far Cry 4 is a fun sandbox of shooting with an interestin... | PC

You Can Control This Guy's Real-Life Christmas Tree From Minecraft

1h ago - This is incredibly cool. Also, given the Internet's proclivity for dousing good intentions in gas... | Culture

Win a PS4!!

Now - Join us on Filmwatch to find out how you can win a free PS4 this holiday season! | Promoted post

A Bravely Default Game Is Headed To Smartphones In Japan

1h ago - Bravely Archive is the series’ first game for smartphones, and it features the world of the Brave... | iPhone