Zhill Olonan wrote: "When Gotham City Impostors was first announced, no one really knew what to make of it. An online-only multiplayer FPS with a cartoonish, exaggerated art style set in the dark world of Gotham City where gangs from two sides (Batman and Joker) duke it out with guns? That is as far from what Batman is supposed to be. Everyone seemed to be wondering if this game was even necessary. Yet, with all the doubts Gotham City Impostors had against it, developer Monolith boldly stuck to their ridiculous premise. And, lo and behold, they released a game that is pure, unadulterated fun."