OXM's Log writes: "When developers show you an open world, it's a slice of cake that they've scooped all the icing onto. "Oh god," you think. You couldn't possibly eat a cake with that much icing on it. You'd die of delicious." You briefly suppress your rationality, and assume that these people aren't misleading you. That technology must have made a massive leap forward while you were wasting your life eating cakes and taking cakey dumps."
More small settlements with characters.
More to do in the wild (fish, collect lumber, set traps and plan ambushes etc)
More usable obstacles (proper rock climbing and tree climbing? Build a home)
I could go on for hourS
I can see the attraction of something like a homestead simulation in TES, where you hunt, farm, fish and raise a family, it'd definitely be cool because farmers and frontiersmen often did go off to seek their fortune, join a bandit crew or fight for the local Lord .
I would love to play Skyrim with my brothers