HD Collections: The Good And The Bad

GamingUnion: "In recent times there has been a lot of popular gaming franchises being re-released in HD, allowing you to have a new way to play some of your favorite games all over again. In most cases an HD collection comes out for two reasons. Firstly, there might be a new game in a popular franchise coming out so they will put out the older games for new fans and old to play them. Secondly, they want to release older games again to promote an anniversary of the series."

[mephman]

I think HD collections are a good thing, especially for bringing gaming to different mediums.

[NastyLeftHook0]

especially sotc and the gow collections, there classics.

[Hisiru]

I believe there is no bad thing about HD Collections.

Nobody is forced to buy.

[badz149]

well
the good? Sony's HD collections are high quality and definitely shows works and efforts have been put into them!

the bad? Ubisoft's and Capcom's HD collections look like cheap cash grabs with no effort, just upgrading the resolution and they still look "last gen"-ish!

[Aloren]

Most, if not all HD collections are just that : cheap cash grabs.

[badz149]

^^^
with or without the effort makes the difference my friend!

[MaxXAttaxX]

Ghost of Sparta looks amazing in HD.

[Aloren]

I guess your definition of efforts makes the difference then...cause so far, I've yet to see any HD collection that doesn't feel like a quick way to make quick cash. I don't mind getting them when the games are great though.

I wouldn't be surprised if the remake of prince of persia on xbla and psn required more "efforts" than GOW HD collection, which is regarded as one of the best HD collection.

[MaxXAttaxX]

@Aloren
Compare Sly PS2 vs PS3 HD.
http://www.flickr.com/photo...
http://www.flickr.com/photo...

Check Sly's character model.
Compare Ico PS2 vs PS3 HD.
http://images.eurogamer.net...
http://images.eurogamer.net...
Check the textures^

[Agent Smith]

Konami, why you mess up Silent Hill HD collection?

[2pacalypsenow]

I have never had a problem with the SH collection on the Ps3 i nver [layed them on the ps2 but i thought they were good ports Also what nightmare part from MG3 was missing ??

[DigitalRaptor]

I haven't read the article, but my opinion is that as long as the collections offer good value for money, are good HD transfers with comprehensive bonuses then I don't see how it's a bad thing. After all, they are not forcing you to re-buy them, and it gives people another chance to experience classics of an era where the experience was more self-contained and not about the obsession with the online deathmatch.

If they cause gaming companies to get complacent and not make new quality games then I can see a problem, but Sony nor other companies have dropped the quality or quantity of their output, so I see hardly any downsides.

[Y_5150]

Without HD collections. Well I wouldn't have gotten into God of war because my PS2 broke and I got a PS3 wishing that I could have tried out the series. I would have missed out on great games with HD collections!

[TheDivine]

I used to say they were cash grabs (many are) but some like the ico collection are a blessing. Replaying classic games in hd (and they usually drop to 20 bucks fast), hell yea! If your happy with mgs on ps2 then fine, im glad to play 2/3/peace walker in hd it amazing. Point is nobody makes you buy them theyre for fans or people who missed out.

[slixshot]

HD Collections also seem like solid starting places for developers to gain some extra revenue and understanding before making their own games. Look at the team behind the new Sly Cooper, they were behind the HD Sly Collection, so not only were they able to gain some extra cash, but they were also able to learn the ins and outs of the Sly games.

[Zha1tan]

While I think HD collections are good for some, for me they do not warrant buying because the game is not remade in HD it just has its resolution upscaled to HD.

If they were all like Halo Anniversery and a graphics overhaul I would get them but as it stands I dont feel they are justified.

[jc48573]

Silent Hill HD Collection is the worst PORT ever.

[bahabeast]

hd collections is a great idea, people who didnt get to play certain games and hear alot about it get to try them out and developers make some more cash on old software. its win win if you ask me personally

[souljah45]

I'm happy with any hd collection handled by bluepoint since there the only ones who get it right.

[fOrlOnhOpe57]

I really want the first Killzone game to be HD remastered - and maybe even released either as a PSN download or on the Killzone 4 blu ray ( as it should have been with either Kz3 or Kz3 .