100°
Submitted by Instigator 1136d ago | review

Atelier Meruru: The Apprentice of Arland Review | IGN

"The Atelier franchise has always walked a fine line between greatness and mediocrity. The games have always been a good step or two shy of becoming excellent, while remaining one false move from being average. Last year's Atelier Totori overcame its flaws with a freeform sense of adventure and a heartfelt story revolving around a sympathetic main character. Sadly, Atelier Meruru: The Apprentice of Arland lacks both of those traits and fails to correct its predecessor's missteps. The result is a game that will disappoint returning fans while remaining too niche to appeal to the greater role-playing game audience at large." (Atelier Meruru: The Apprentice of Arland, PS3) 6/10

Son_Lee  +   1136d ago
I hate how IGN (and other sites) will lower a game's score (RPGs mainly) just because it doesn't appeal to everyone.

NO game appeals to everyone! If the game is good, let it stand on its own merits, whether it will be for the masses or not.
Canary  +   1136d ago
That's kind of the problem: the game may not have to, but IGN ~does~ have to appeal to the masses. That's why they typically review games after only a couple hours, routinely mark down Japanese titles and niche titles, and laud undue praise on blockbusters.

Just go back and read their reviews for Dragon Age 2, Mass Effect 3, Assassin's Creed, etc.
nirr   1136d ago | Spam
Baka-akaB  +   1136d ago
IGNorants strike again , nothing to see , let's move on .

It's yet another review dumped onto some freelancer .
#3 (Edited 1136d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Final Fantasy VII G-Bike’s Latest Event Adds Phoenix And A New Bike

7m ago - Final Fantasy VII G-Bike is a smartphone game based on the Final Fantasy VII mini-game, except yo... | iPhone
20°

7 Female Characters Changing the Face of Video Game Heroes

40m ago - Playboy: When it comes to main characters in video games—and even secondary characters to a large... | PC
Ad

Win a Grim Dawn Steam Key and GameMaker: Studio Professional

Now - Today we have ten, count them, ten Grim Dawn Steam codes to give away! | Promoted post
20°

Japanese Game Composers Made A Free Album To Get Closer To Western Fans

1h ago - Want a free album made by some of the top Japanese game composers? Well, here you go. | Culture
20°

Anima: Gate of Memories Will Be Released In The Next Few Months

1h ago - Action RPG Anima: Gate of Memories has been greenlit on Steam and will be released on PC within t... | PC
20°

7 Video Games That Had Gay Marriage Before it was Cool

1h ago - Hicuo: "The world of video games has its own issues when it comes to inclusiveness, and as in the... | PC