Uncharted 2, More Perfect Scores than Halo 3 and Gears of War

GWAVE - 60 days 12 hours ago

This is just my personal opinion/prediction, but I don't think MW2 will live up to the hype. It will sell a TON, but Infinity Ward just seems like they're making the player too much of a super-soldier. Certain review sites will shower it with praise, but my guess is that it will land somewhere between a 90 and 93 on Metacritic.

Oh, and Little Big Planet is also higher-rated than Halo 3 or Gears. MGS4 has the same average as Halo 3 and it is higher-rated than Gears (and besides, we all know Halo 3's high score was very undeserved).

Agree(42) | Disagree(5) | Report

militant07 - 60 days 11 hours ago

halo 3 deserve its score, the most played game on XBL since FALL 2007.

no matter how you bash it, HALO 3 still win.

Agree(15) | Disagree(91) | Report

kwicksandz - 60 days 10 hours ago

If anything LBP was overrated as the reviewers didnt experience the horribly broken launch of the game. it wasnt socom bad but it was certainly troublesome.

To this day the online is sketchy at best

Agree(5) | Disagree(52) | Report

StanLee - 60 days 10 hours ago

How is this significant? GTAIV has how many perfect scores? Uncharted 2 is far from being a perfect game. A perfect score is only indicative of how much a reviewer has bought into the excitement of a game and then a few month later he's reflective and realizes that, maybe I wasn't objective in reviewing this game. And this goes for all the highly lauded games this gen, not just Uncharted 2 or Halo 3 or GTAIV or Gears of War. I know when I played those games I was awed but a few months later, I played the same game and realize the shallowness of the story, the repetitive gameplay and having been familiar with the title, how little content it offers. That's why so many games this generation are labeled overrated but who "overrated" them in the first place. We did, reviewers did, because in that moment, we aren't being objective, we're relishing the experience.

Edit; Wow, so many disagress. Yay for the immaturity of fanboys.

Agree(6) | Disagree(64) | Report

kapedkrusader - 60 days 10 hours ago

...Tetris is probably the most played game ever, but I still wouldn't say it's better than Halo.

Agree(23) | Disagree(5) | Report

LinuxGuru - 60 days 10 hours ago

Solitaire is probably the most played game in any form, in the world.

That doesn't mean it provides a better experience than whatever else is out there.

Your logic fails, militant07

Agree(32) | Disagree(4) | Report

Xeoset - 60 days 10 hours ago

How did THIS get approved? Yay for fanboy warfare.

£50 for an experience that'll last 2 weeks.
£30 for an experience that has survived 2 years and will continue to until...Halo 4?

Think I'd rather know which I'd rather have, even if I do have to sacrifice a 0.2 average.

Mydays =P

EDIT:

1.4 - I couldn't agree more personally. GTAIV won so many 10/10's and I had to strive to finish it personally. After playing UC1 on my girlfriends PS3, I wasn't too impressed and it got great scores. Guess this is another one of those stories.

Agree(2) | Disagree(48) | Report

gaffyh - 60 days 10 hours ago

I wonder what all the Xbox fans would be saying if the title was about an Xbox game beating a PS3 game?

Xbox fans heads seem to be exploding at the idea of this being true, even though it's based 100% on facts. Lol.

Agree(21) | Disagree(1) | Report

Lifendz - 60 days 10 hours ago

but it's been surpassed by Uncharted 2. Nothing got stale. The game never got tedious. Last night I had that "I can't put the controller down" moment. Loving the game and I haven't even touched the multi-player yet.

Agree(14) | Disagree(0) | Report

Daver - 60 days 10 hours ago

Assassins creed 2 even if you liked it or not is a contender for GOTY

Agree(3) | Disagree(13) | Report

nycredude - 60 days 10 hours ago

I love how 360 fans say they played the game or the first one and say they weren't impressed. I wonder what does impress them because I own a 360 and most of the "critically acclaimed" games on it and IMHO not one of them is even close to as impressive as UC1 and UC2.

So to each his own I guess.

Agree(29) | Disagree(2) | Report

Isaac - 60 days 10 hours ago

"halo 3 deserve its score"

Not really, it's just a rehash of halo 2 which is also a rehash of halo 1 with online play, which happens to be a rehash of all other FPS that came before. Hell, it didn't invent dual gun wielding nor health re-gen (as if "re-gen" was more realistic anyway).

"the most played game on XBL since FALL 2007. "

That's because most people don't know anything else, not because it's *that* good.

Agree(21) | Disagree(5) | Report

lowcarb - 60 days 10 hours ago

They would be acting the same way as ps3 fanboys.

Agree(3) | Disagree(17) | Report

Unicron - 60 days 10 hours ago

Why do people care so much about scores? The game is what it is, not because of what number some rando assigns to it.

Agree(5) | Disagree(1) | Report

Harry_Manback - 60 days 10 hours ago

I haven't gotten any sleep since Tuesday. The game refuses to let me put the controller down! :)
And I also need to get back to Demon's Souls.

Agree(9) | Disagree(0) | Report

gaffyh - 60 days 10 hours ago

@1.13 - Exactly, so they have no right to complain.

@1.14 - Same reason why people care about sales info, graphics comparison and gamesthirst articles.

Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report

Tinted Eyes - 60 days 9 hours ago

D-D-D-D-Damage Control!!!!!!!

I should have specified, not just you, the other 360 fans. But you seem to take this very seriously

Agree(11) | Disagree(3) | Report

FlipMode - 60 days 9 hours ago

Nice headline. lol

Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report

bjornbear - 60 days 9 hours ago

Its not a game...its an experience =D And MP is soooo FUUUN O.O had to stop been playing for 4 hours straight =S

Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report

The-Warranty - 60 days 9 hours ago

Uncharted better than any 360 exclusive confirmed.

Agree(12) | Disagree(0) | Report

Darkeyes - 60 days 8 hours ago

What a bunch of hypocrites... All the 360 fanboys doing damage control would do the same thing if a 360 game was so universally acclaimed.

@Arbitrator.... Yours is the dumbest logic I have come across for not playing on PSN... Don't want to play since you don't want to be friends with PS3 fanboys LMAO.

//Rant starts...
And all those complaining about this site being ruled by PS3 fanboys just STFU.. If it hurts you so much, then don't visit the site or create multiple accounts like you do when your bubbles run out so you can show that there are equal no of fanboys from both sites (and hit the disagree button to your hearts content).. Ya there are more PS3 FB here than 360 whatch gonna do eh???? You can't stop people from coming to this site.

And I completely agree with the headline... Infact I have a better headline -"Uncharted 2, More Perfect scores than ANY 360 exclusive till date..." Take that. I have played nearly all the so called 360 AAA titles (most on my PC) and none of them even holds a candle in front of Uncharted 2. Neither Gears nor Halo nor Mass Effect nor L4D.... This is a gen defining gem and I don't care if it sells 2 million in it's lifetime.. It's a game you have to EXPERIENCE to see what the hype is about.. SALEZ SALEZ SALEZ.. Lol ya ODST sold 2 million first day !!! OH sooo good... Don't know how that turns you on, but more than 25 perfect scores is something to brag about.... Uncharted 2.... Gen defining game...
Rant ends//

Agree(8) | Disagree(1) | Report

StanLee - 60 days 8 hours ago

I'll take the opportunity now to brag about GTAIV's 50 plus perfect scores. I'd also like to take the opportunity to mention that LittleBigPlanet has more perfect scores than Halo 3, Uncharted 2 and Gears of War.

Edit @ Darkeyes

Dude, you can say what you want but fanboys are hypocrites. How can you say Uncharted's and LittleBigPlanet's perfect scores are deserved and Halo 3s and GTAIV's isn't? Shut to hell up you idiotic fanboy.

Agree(0) | Disagree(10) | Report

sikbeta - 60 days 8 hours ago

I love Uncharted so much, so I don't need to compare with any other game and neither all of you, Halo has his fanbase, the same with GeOW, but I really hope UC2 be GOTY and not MW2

Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report

Xiphos - 60 days 8 hours ago

...and they didn't have to send out $800 bribe bags to do it. Great work, Naughty Dog.

Agree(8) | Disagree(0) | Report

Darkeyes - 60 days 8 hours ago

Ya you can do that all you like.. LBP deserved it cause it brought something new to the table and yes it deserved those scores... GTA was all hype and no show same as ODST. You get perfect scores for just having a brand name and that is what is seen (and frankly remove GTA and Halo tag behind these 2 games and they won't even get a single full score).... And sometimes 800$ goodie bags from M$ also works magic on devs.

And actually speaking, I don't mind you bragging these games... Both are on the PS3 so it's doesn't matter to me much.. I'll still stand by my statement that GTA4 was POS as compared to GTA:SA. Even Saints Row 2 was better IMO.
But I realy recommend you Uncharted 2. I have my opinion cause I have played the games and yes it's the best game I have played this gen... Above Gears (yup I like Gears), MGS4 and Killzone 2... In fact it takes all the elements of above games (Cover from Gears, Cinematic/deep story elements from MGS4 and graphics from KZ2) and tops everyone of them.... It's GOTY and if ANY game wants to win that honor this year, then it has to be something extra ordinary...

Agree(6) | Disagree(2) | Report

beans - 60 days 8 hours ago

You sir are spot on. I'm sure this game is great but it's come to my attention that none of these reviews should even be taken serious. All of these sites are just trying to stay in business and not get hammered by Sony trolls which I completely understand. Unicron was also spot on when he said "Why do people care so much about scores? The game is what it is, not because of what number some rando assigns to it." because that all people care about now.

Agree(1) | Disagree(10) | Report

JBaby343 - 60 days 6 hours ago

Seems a lot of people are upset it's not 2007 anymore while a lot more are glad it's not 2007 anymore. Which group are you in?

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report

ico92 - 60 days 6 hours ago

uncharted 2 is the 5th highest rated game of all time and the 2nd highest rated exclusive this gen on gamerankings (after mario galaxy) im not sure if halo 3 and gears are in top 50

Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report

n4f - 60 days 6 hours ago

flaimbait article
second it will win goty anyway
third modern warfare 2 will get in the same range of metacritic
fourth so what?

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report

redsquad - 60 days 5 hours ago

Hey "Kingme", you lose.
Look at the threads about UNCHARTED day one sales and see the 360 owners saying "LOL is that all" or "Left for Dead sold more". See that gobsh1te who posted spoilers in multiple threads while adding "LOL" to them because he was so 'clever'.

Don't come with the pretentious high horse act here chum...

Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report

mal_tez92 - 60 days 4 hours ago

The fact that GTA IV is the highest rated game ever is proof that review scores aren't that meaningful, both me and my brother got bored of it in less than a week.

Uncharted 2 however I believe does deserve the scores it's getting. Just like Drake's Fortune, it delivers an amazing experience, but this time it is full of epic moments. I don't think any other game has this level of action in it; MGS4 or Half-Life 2 come close, but I said "WHOAH" a lot more times in Uncharted 2.

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report

Xbox Avatars Shoe - 59 days 23 hours ago

WTF is IGN talking about?!

I just got the game today and beat the first stealth level on my first try! IGN said the game didn't explain stealth gameplay well enough in the beginning which caused them to mess up a lot WTF?! It was extremely easy to understand the stealth mechanic; stay out of the enemies line-of-sight and melee them from behind. What's hard about that?! It's not like you have to carefully watch how well you blend in with the environment, stay in the shadows and then run up to an enemy press a precise button combo.

IGN took away 0.5 points for a flaw that doesn't even exist.

Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report

3XP - 59 days 23 hours ago

Man, you nailed it. You are 100 percent correct.

I have a PS3, but I don't play it. If you do decide that you still want one. PM me, I will give you a good deal on the one I have as long as you don't mind brushing the dust off of it.

I stop playing on PSN also, the the reason I stopped is because the dudes on PSN, just don't have the skill like those on XBL...haha

Agree(0) | Disagree(3) | Report

zootang - 60 days 11 hours ago

Mr pope man, is it true that people that only own 360 play sales and not games?

Agree(26) | Disagree(2) | Report

Pope_John_Paul_II - 60 days 10 hours ago

yes.

Agree(16) | Disagree(3) | Report

Bzone24 - 60 days 10 hours ago

You do realize if a game is bought, most likely it's played? The whole "playing sales" talking point that the ps3 fanboys bring up is the stupidest argument I've ever heard in my life. Maybe they are just jealous or something? Not sure. I just know it's brought up whenever they feel threatened about Xbox 360 game sales.

I do know that it's ok to bring up sales whenever a ps3 game sells good though. It's not "playing sales", it's just being happy about a game you enjoy doing well. A 360 fan does the same and it's "playing sales". Guess I just don't get it.

Agree(4) | Disagree(12) | Report

Knghtz - 60 days 9 hours ago

I agree with Elisha Cuthbert.

Cuthbert > Pope. There I said it!

Agree(1) | Disagree(6) | Report

Sarcasm - 60 days 9 hours ago

"it's just being happy about a game you enjoy doing well."

Uhmm... no.

When a PS3 gamer praises a PS3 game let's say about graphics or gameplay, like... Killzone 2. You know what a 360 fanboy retaliates with?

"HA! Killzone 2 only sold 2 million. Halo 3 sold 10 million!"

Is that "being happy about a game you enjoy doing well?"

No. That's fanboyism. Which is what they refer to as "Playing Sales"

The fact is, Sales =/= Quality.

So stop trying to spin it like it's some innocent reactions.

Agree(9) | Disagree(3) | Report

Pope_John_Paul_II - 60 days 9 hours ago

as a PS3 owner i want it to sell, because it deserves it. Not for Hype, but because of the experience that is worth the $60.

People Bought GTAIV and Halo 3 mainly for Hype, and look at the disappointment.

Agree(7) | Disagree(2) | Report

The Wood - 60 days 8 hours ago

let me help you on the 'playing sales' argument. For a while it was all about the exclusives and the graphics...once the ps3 caught up/passed the 360 on both of these it moved to 'teh sales' A simple analogy is what made more at the box office Spiderman 3 or the departed. The answer is spiderman 3 but we all know that the departed was/is the better film so sales do not equate to quality which 'some' 360 fanboys love to speak about.

The point is we are gamers not 'patchers' and your one copy is all you can play. Maybe if 2 trillion people buy the game then the online community will be more expansive but you can only ever play so many people and you'll never face everybody so thats a questionable advantage unless those trillions can create levels ie lbp or those same trillions still play the game now like halo 3 or modern warfare (cod 4). Secondly sales do not need to hit 2 trillion or halo/gran turismo/wi fit numbers to warrant a sequel as motorstorm, uncharted, Resistance, Ratchet etc have proved. With this being said if you only ever opened your eyes to BOTH side of the fanboys NOT just the ps3 ones you'd notice that sales of halo and gears seem to come up a lot. I'd prefer if gamers spoke about graphics gameplay or general quality NOT how many copies x sold. Both side are full of hypocritical sh*t so this isnt just about either side in particular im just responding to 'teh sales' argument. Remember that Gran turismo has still sold more than forza (gt5p even sold more than forza 2) but will that stop 360 fans from enjoying or lording it.....doubt it and why should it.

teh sales is the last argument for some 360 fans.

Agree(6) | Disagree(1) | Report

sikbeta - 60 days 8 hours ago

You really don't know what you are talking about, xbox fanboys play sales and comparisons, they don't care about quality when you talk about every game, If a PS3 owner prize the sales of a game because It deserve (quality game), xbox fanboys say: I thought sales don't matter to you (PS3 owners) and when the game doesn't sell like crazy they say: flop, doesn't live to the hype, quantity > quality and many more stupid things

Agree(4) | Disagree(1) | Report

STICKzophrenic - 60 days 8 hours ago

"People Bought GTAIV and Halo 3 mainly for Hype, and look at the disappointment."

Who is disappointed? Certainly not the Halo 3 fans who play it every day and make it the top played game on XBL.

Certainly not the GTA IV fans who play it every day and make it the eighth most played game on XBL.

Hmmm, I think it's just PS3 fanboys who are disappointed that PS3 exclusives aren't played as much as other games.

Me personally? I don't care about sales. It's nice to see awesome games sell well, because that most likely ensures a sequel, but if I own the game and enjoy it, what do I care if 2 million other people bought it?

As for reviews I do use them to an extent, but usually if a game to which I'm looking forward receives around 80% to 85%, then it just reinforces my purchase. I don't think any game is entitled to receive 10/10 from every single website.

By the way, Uncharted 2 is an amazing experience and I'm glad I bought into the hype and got it. Kudos to Naughty Dog for making such an awesome game.

Agree(2) | Disagree(3) | Report

rekonizakilla - 60 days 10 hours ago

Did you lose a bet or something?

Agree(7) | Disagree(1) | Report

dredgewalker - 60 days 10 hours ago

Good Lordy MGR!! Get a hold of yourself.....were you visited by tall guys wearing a black suit?

Agree(5) | Disagree(0) | Report

54percent - 60 days 6 hours ago

he just want bubbles

Agree(6) | Disagree(0) | Report

dustgavin - 60 days 4 hours ago

"Thats true because its way better in graphics and gameplay.
I like ps3 now ."

MetalGearRising - 59 minutes ago

PM
Track
Ignore
8 -
Uncharted 2 Hyped by Sony and Naughty Dog as being one of the best looking game ever and yet it even fails to move a Million day 1. Even Naughty Dog have been talking sh*t how great uncharted 2 is and the process of what went in to producing this so called game so why does it FAIL at selling WHY. Then you pathetic droids say GOTY my ass its GOTY. Only games that deserve GOTY are the ones that sell Over a MILLION.

Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report

GWAVE - 60 days 12 hours ago

And neither Halo nor Gears will ever match the sales of Mario Kart or Wii Fit.

Lulz. See how important sales are?

Agree(23) | Disagree(1) | Report

Pope_John_Paul_II - 60 days 11 hours ago

i guess wiifit is the greatest video game ever made if you go by sales..NOOOOO.

Agree(12) | Disagree(0) | Report

gaffyh - 60 days 11 hours ago

So you don't play games, you play sales?

It's News 4 Gamers, not News 4 Salesman.

Agree(17) | Disagree(1) | Report

W831SOLIDSNAKE - 60 days 10 hours ago

And Kias sell more then ferrari, yet that doesn't make them a better car.....you're a fool HAHAHA
PS3 is king.

P.S Forza 3 sucks

Agree(9) | Disagree(0) | Report

54percent - 60 days 6 hours ago

halo and gears sell more cuz they are for kidz and poor people

Agree(3) | Disagree(2) | Report

2good4u2 - 60 days 3 hours ago

how's it for poor people? were they cheaper than uncharted? same price here...

gears for kids makes even less sence. too bad you're not allowed to play it yet, but you'd love it!

Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report

PlayStation X - 60 days 10 hours ago

and pigs can fly =/

but seriously tho, it doubt it will look as good as uncharted 1. bungie are still struggling to make games in hd ffs

Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report

redsquad - 60 days 6 hours ago

Who said they exchanged 'tech'?

Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report

PlayStation X - 60 days 10 hours ago

no multiplatform games are =/

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report

Pennywise - 60 days 9 hours ago

BIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIPOLAR!

Agree(7) | Disagree(0) | Report

Doc Sony - 60 days 9 hours ago

aaahh, there's the Rising I know, I was beginning to get a little worried.

You xbots are so game starved that you have to brag and boast about multiplatform stuff.

Agree(8) | Disagree(1) | Report

talltony - 60 days 9 hours ago

If you played uncharted 2 you would know without of doubt that it couldnt be done on 360 ever! I would love to see your reaction playing it. Their are things that are just so dang impressive in it. But i understand your just desperate now, talking about a new cry engine which is really just crysis on medium settings even though killzone 2 was already compared to cry engine 2 on high settings which is better by the way..

Agree(5) | Disagree(0) | Report

emkize - 60 days 5 hours ago

Do everyone a favor and keep your mouth shut about topics you know nothing about. You little nitwit.

Guess who's going to develop a game using Cryengine 3. Crytek will, and it will be cross-platform.

I want you to name all the games you've played on Cryengine 2 and who made them.

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report

TheBand1t - 60 days 9 hours ago

You fail at spoilers. And you also prove you didn't play the game.

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report

TheDynamo - 60 days 7 hours ago

He may be Pro-360, but he speaks the truth.

I have a question too...

I keep hearing, "PS3 Gamers don't play sales, we play GAMES."

I think it's HILARIOUS.

This is the second best reviewed game this generation allegedly.

Shouldn't the fanbase support this massive game and purchase it in MASS numbers? But they won't.

And then the excuse as always is, "Because we have variety."

Weak.

Support this incredible developer with this incredible game. They deserve it.

And prove to THEM and XBOX360 fans that a blockbuster is possible on PS3.

You can end the criticism "that people buy the PS3 for BluRay."

Naughty Dog deserves it. DON'T THEY?

Agree(3) | Disagree(4) | Report

Pennywise - 60 days 7 hours ago

o o o ... can I join the circle jerk?

Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report

IcyJoker187 - 60 days 6 hours ago

When they cant have quality, they run to sales, Hilarious.

Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report

TheDynamo - 60 days 5 hours ago

Instead of answering the question, you divert attention to something else.

I bought Uncharted 1, Killzone 2, and Infamous.

I support Sony and I support Microsoft.

Why don't you go and buy the game?
Tell your friends to.
Tell your online compadres to.

Naughty Dog should have a blockbuster on their hands.

But something tells me that they won't. Why?

Because a lot of so-called Sony supporters are all talk and no action.

For once, you should try to discuss instead of hiding...

Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report