Dark Souls review (PS3)

Blastoise | 539d ago | User review
Reviewing: Dark Souls
Imminent Masterpiece
Dark Souls is a game like no other, it does away with quick time events, hand holding & the cinematic characters we're all so used to these days. It reminds me why I play games in the first place, for the reward, the atmosphere & the adventure. It reminds me that us as gamers, should change to fit the game, to improve. Instead of the games catering to us. For me at least, It was a glimmer of hope amongst a sea of shooters. A deep rewarding experience that wasn't aimed at the masses, but was clearly created with passion.

After creating your character, and personalising them with a few hair and facial tweaks, one who can be many of your usual RPG classes, be it a mage, knight or miracle user. You play as the chosen undead, a poor soul destined to live in the Undead Asylum until the end of time. You are however, given a little bit of help to escape your cell. And you set of on your adventure to bring pilgrimage to the land of the ancient Lords, Lordran.
You're then taken to the firelink shrine, here is where your journey truly begins. This is the closest thing you'll get to "Home" in what is otherwise a rather bleak world.

In an industry now prone to taking the controller off of you, & showing you the story through cut-scenes, this game is pretty much the exact opposite. The story is there, but like everything else, Dark souls isn't going to bend over backwards to make sure you understand it. The main plot is told through a few pieces of NPC dialogue, and the voice over at the start. Everything else you'll have to learn on your own. Any background stories of the wonderfully weird NPC's you'll have to piece together yourself. Through subtle hints in their dialogue, to vague descriptions of their sold items. Dark Souls' plot is the video game equivalent of a jigsaw, for better or worse, you'll get as much out of it as you put into it.

After being told to ring one of two bells, you'll soon learn Dark Souls combat is based largely on accuracy & precision. Timing your attacks right and exploiting an enemies weakness is the key to success. Fighting too offensively at times will get you killed, where as doing the opposite at other times will end in the same outcome. Defeating one of the many strange & occasionally disturbing enemies will give you souls. Unsurprisingly, souls are everything in this game, your currency to buy arrows from the oddly camp merchant in the Undead Burg. As well as levelling up your character to suit your magic, vitality or endurance needs. Levelling up your character is incredibly satisfying, you will always feel your character's benefits. To increasing your Intelligence stat for that more powerful magical spell, to rising your strength to use that one obscure weapon you retrieved from a boss. Armour sets are really detailed & abnormal. It's clear Dark Souls has had a Japanese influence & it is entirely beneficial for it. Items are mysterious & weapons are bizarre.

You'll accompany your character through some incredibly varied and beautiful environments.
The Darkroot garden, a wonderfully green forest home to strange bush monsters, large fierce cats & unofficial gathering place of "no rules PVP". Anor londo, a huge city bathed in sunlight, with an almost eary sense of artificiality with it's unstained and sanitary architecture. The crystal cave, a cave concealed in bright blue rocks, a place hard to admire by the habit of getting wacked in the face by a crystal golem.
All of this is partnered with the fact that the world is intertwined, it's all to scale. You can sit atop sens fortress and look down upon where you previously fought the Gargoyles, you can look up from atop the undead Parish Church & view what you'll later learn to be the Dukes Archives. All of this comes together to make Lordran an entirely immersive world.

The online in Dark Souls is in my opinion, revolutionary. Not every JRPG needs online, but Dark Souls proves the genre can benefit a lot from more player interaction. Players can leave each other messages, be it a warning or tip. Or a downright lie, to help/fool other players. You'll often find "Bonfire ahead" near a bonfire, or a "Be wary of blacksmith" before meeting a friendly blacksmith. You may sometimes find "Amazing treasure ahead" right before a fatal drop though (seems legit), so don't put too much trust in these messages. Nevertheless, they help remind you that you're not entirely alone on your quests, and other people may be facing the same hardships as you.
Which brings me to the CO-OP, players can use an item called Humanity, a black sprite which doesn't look entirely unlike a vagina, to turn human. Turning human allows you to summon fellow Dark Souls players to help you face that particular areas boss. Phantoms who are successful in helping you with Jolly co-operation, are rewarded with their own humanity sprite. Which in turn lets them turn human.
Defeating a boss with another player or two is a journey, an experience no other co-op game has given me. You'll form a temporary bond with these phantoms. A brief moment of companionship before braving the twisted enemies of Lordran alone. A feeling Demon's Souls players will likely remember. There is no online chat, that's not how Dark souls rolls. Instead players communicate in gestures, be it a shrug, a bow or a point. This creates some amusing moments, like a gleeful jump when defeating a particularly tough enemy. Or a synchronised shrug, when a fellow phantom accidently rolls off a cliff to his death, in his haste to dodge a sword wielding skeleton.

There are downsides to being human though, being human allows other players to invade your world, in an attempt to kill you. This is the player versus player aspect of Dark Souls. If successful in killing you, and probably screwing up the 2 hours you just spent trekking through Blighttown, the Invader will take your humanity. If a player is successful in defending against an invader, the player will be given humanity, as well as a horde of souls in accordance to the invader's level.
This creates for some heart racing moments, as there is so much to lose. There are few moments in gaming that get your blood pumping as much as seeing "Insert Japanese Name Here Has Invaded" to then meet a bright red phantom flipping at you, holding a magically enhanced katana. Possibly using some kind of spell that you have yet to encounter.

Adding more depth to the already fantastic multiplayer is the ability to join covenants.
Covenants provide certain item's and open up certain possibilities to multiplayer. For example, to help a further range of people in Co-op, or to host a PvP duel. Players can join or leave any covenant at any time, though some will have consequences. Covenants are found across the whole of Lordran, some will take effort to find, some will be there right in front of you. It is entirely possible you will go through the game without finding certain ones.

The music is always stunning & always very relevant to the atmosphere. You'll hear a variety of tunes on your travels, for the "safer" more calm area's the music will be in accordance, the Firelink shrines theme is almost relaxing. The boss battles on the other hand are a different story, being a big part of the game they demand more powerful and memorable themes, and they always deliver. Ornstein and Smoughs theme is particularly memorable, a dread filling theme with effective Organs, Violins & what I can only describe as "HUUUURRRRRR HUUUURRRRRR". Also, the ending theme is beautiful. An elegant & delicate theme which somehow manages to capture the emotion I felt from completing the game.

However, no game is perfect. Unfortunately there are a few framerate problems in certain area's of the game, luckily though the framerate is relatively solid & the only issues you'll find are in these few places, which can be completed with relative ease & hold no hotspots for online play. There are times when the game throws it's "firm but fair" rule out the window, and just likes to surprise you with an almost unavoidable death, which can result in an almost instant ragequit. Online can hold a few troublesome issues too, PVP can occasionally lag, and you may be victim to the infamous "lagstab". A critical hit which may feel like you've been cheated out of a potential victory. Summon sign's can sometimes fail too, though this is a rather small issue. Overall, these are minor problems, and should not discourage anyone from attempting any portion of the multiplayer options.

To put it short, everyone should play Dark Souls. The atmosphere, armour design, unique monsters, deep RPG mechanics, NPC's, vast world, music, secrets & online play all come together to create a masterpiece of the genre. A game I believe is worth a place in any gaming history books. Praise the sun!
Ups
Masterful Soundtrack
Deep RPG Mechanics
Vast & Varied World
Downs
Occasional Framerate Problems
Score
9.0
Graphics Great graphics, detailed armour sets, monsters & bosses. Art style is what makes it truly impressive though.
10.0
Sound Motoi Sakuraba deserves recognition.
10.0
Gameplay Accuracy, patience & timing is rewarded.
9.0
Fun factor Despite a couple of rage worthy moments (And there will be some), A very rewarding experience.
9.0
Online Other than an occasional "WTF?!". Dark Souls shines when with others, be it PVP or Jolly co-operation.
10.0
Overall (out of 10 / not an average)
DragonKnight  +   538d ago
Damn, I didn't even know that Motoi Sakuraba did the music for Dark Souls, it's so different from what he normally does. Look at his Star Ocean tracks for example. I wonder if Dark Souls would suffer if he had put at least one heavy guitar track for a boss fight. Might be epic.
Blacktric  +   538d ago
"Ornstein and Smoughs theme is particularly memorable, a dread filling theme with effective Organs, Violins & what I can only describe as "HUUUURRRRRR HUUUURRRRRR""

http://www.youtube.com/watc...

Oh and, thanks a lot for the awesome review. Praise the sun!
Blastoise  +   538d ago
No problem dude, glad you liked it!
HarryMasonHerpderp  +   538d ago
Nice review Blastoise.
You described the game very well.
I personally liked Demon Souls more than Dark Souls but they are equally as good for different reasons.
I hope to read a Dark Souls 2 review from you in the future. I would like to know how you feel about the changes since it won't have Hidetaka Miyazaki directing the game.
TheoreticalParticle  +   538d ago
You do not know what the word "imminent" means.

You are looking for this word.

http://dictionary.reference...
-GametimeUK-  +   537d ago
I read the phrase "imminent masterpiece" and thought nothing of it. I read it as the author was intending to imply that sometime in the future we will reflect on Dark Souls as a masterpiece after it has stood the test of time (as in one day it will the title "masterpiece").

I think his use of the word was justified...

... but there still is the possibility you are correct in what you are saying lol.
Blastoise  +   537d ago
Well you could take it like that I suppose, with my conclusion at the end this is very much a game I think we'll look at in future of one of the highlights of this gen. But really it was in reference to the in-game messages you find on the floor

I definitely didnt mean eminent -.-'
TheoreticalParticle  +   537d ago
So, if that's what you're going for, neither of those words work.

Imminent means that it's about to happen immediately. As in, any minute now, everyone's going to wake up and realize that Dark Souls was a masterpiece.

Your article was pointing to a future far enough away where we'd be looking back at this gen and picking out games that were gems. That's further into the future than the definition of imminent allows for.
HarryMasonHerpderp  +   537d ago
It's a Dark Souls reference stop herp derping.
PM him if it's bothering you that much and stop clogging up the comments with posts nobody cares about.
#4.2.1 (Edited 537d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(2) | Report
-GametimeUK-  +   537d ago
Whenever someone asks me what my fave game of the generation is I always reply with Uncharted 2, Super Mario Galaxy and a few other titles. However, my play time on Dark Souls is quite high and is probably my most played game. I would have to say that it is probably my best game this gen (but Uncharted 2 is sooo awesome). The only thing I didn't like about the game is the fact that there isn't much need to invade people. In Demon's Souls I think they balanced the risk / reward for playing in human and soul form a lot better. Loss of HP in soul form, potential loss of ring slot to remedy the situation a bit. You want your HP and the ability to summon others? Either be evil and invade or be good and coop. It worked perfectly.

Needless to say my gripe is very tiny. I think Dark Souls is better than Demons Souls. I can run through the game now and learn new things. The more you put in to the game will decide how much you get out of it. A lot better than most games today where you put little effort in and see the whole experience in 6 - 10 hours (the industry has a place for these games, but does it have to be nearly every single title?).

Good review :-)
#5 (Edited 537d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
OcelotRigz  +   535d ago
Good point regarding play-time.
I always considered RPGs time soaking games, i spent a hell of a lot time playing Fallout 3, Oblivion, etc... i reckon around 50hrs, im not sure but its way more that any other game.
Then i play Demon Souls, which i spent good hours on but when i finished it i was eager to play Dark Souls and the amount of time i put into that game is ridiculous when compared to any other game, i have 4 characters and for 3 of them i have over 100hrs logged in, altogether i have around 350/360hrs. That is amazing value for money consider you pay €50 for most games and finish them in 6-9hrs, excluding multiplayer.

That shows not only how great these games are, but it also puts other games, and developers, to shame.
#5.1 (Edited 535d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
g-nome  +   537d ago
A fantastic frantic world that will consume your soul.
MrChow666  +   537d ago
Im playing it right now for the first time, its very similar to demons souls but I would say this is notoriously harder or unforgiving and I love it for that, most games today dont offer a decent challenge, this one sure does, not only of skill but patience and memory. The art style and the mood are supperb, its soooo dark. I'm really enjoying it
SageHonor  +   537d ago
I actually just bought this. 20 dollars new. Quite the bargain!
MrChow666  +   534d ago
yeah I got it for 15 Euros, its really cheap now and it has much more playtime and quality in it than 90% of the games, you cant go wrong buying it
TheOneEyedHound  +   536d ago
I think Demon's Souls is much better, but sure was a great game.
OcelotRigz  +   536d ago
I think Dark Souls is the better game, but i had the better, and unforgettable, experience with Demon Souls. If that makes sense.

Either way, two of my favorite games this gen, well actually ever, really. It was a shining light of an old school adventure game and originality that shone thru all the grayness and sameness of fps's and blockbuster games/movies that we've seen this generation.

Great review, its always nice to see other people who appreciate a game just as much as you do.
TheOneEyedHound  +   535d ago
The first time experience I had with Demon Souls was unbelieve able.

What makes me pick Demons Souls over Dark Souls, was the Nexus. The felling like you are safe, was simply the best.

The nexus had it's own atmosphere, with wonderful characters. In Dark Souls it felt rush, or when you had to go back to a previous level, you had to run through levels. I also loved the online servers for Demon Souls a lot more, it was much more dedicated.
OcelotRigz  +   535d ago
I agree, i played Demon Souls first, i never once played online since i was too late to the party, but nonetheless, because i didn't play Dark Souls i didn't know what i was missing and i had great experience. Demon Souls was definitely more immersive, the way the world pulls you in and you are completely focused when playing. At times it was horrifying, nerve wrecking etc... but all in a good way, a thrilling way. For example, the most haunting level ive ever played was the prison. I'll never forget it, the atmosphere was unbelievable, the moans, the maze-like design, the creepy wardens and the guy banging the bars and roaring.

It was a relief to hop back to the nexus now and again, i agree, but even the characters there were so creepy, with such melancholy and also the way they sometimes ended their conversation with a eerie laugh, so i was always on edge.

Dark Souls carried on the experience but for me, the atmosphere wasn't as unnerving and i felt the online system, the way you could get invaded (which was a first for me) kinda replaced that atmosphere with one of tension. Also, i found Dark Souls a more easy going experience maybe because i felt Demon Souls was harsher and i was well prepared. I had no problem with the lack of a nexus, i liked the fireplace, i think its a nice touch especially the way you see other characters resting too. The travelling could get annoying but for me it was a way to pick up extra souls and anyway it was pretty much solved later in the game.

Again, Demon Souls was the better experience but for me i kinda see both games as the same experience, so thats why its hard to choose one. Great great games, i really hope they dont ruin it with DS2, i didn't like a lot of the stuff i was reading about that.
#9.2 (Edited 535d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Number-Nine  +   535d ago
Demon's MP was much better too.
TheOneEyedHound  +   535d ago
Agree, I knew you were going to name that level, I agree it being the creepiest.

Another thing I forgot to mention, I also loved the World Tendency system in Demon's Souls. There was nothing like doing it the hard way, helping people online so your tendency would go white, or wait for a day were the tendency was all black (Halloween).
Bio_Mod  +   534d ago
Both are excellent currently playing a new character in dark souls at Sens fortress I forgot about all the nasty surprises until last night.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember

Dark Souls

Average Score 9.1 Reviews(182)
Release Dates
PC Release Dates
PS3 Release Dates
US 04 October 2011
EU 07 October 2011
AU 07 October 2011
Wii U Release Dates
Xbox 360 Release Dates
US 04 October 2011
EU 07 October 2011
AU 07 October 2011