1130°

Ellen Page Claims Naughty Dog "Ripped Off" her Likeness

Rely on Horror: People have been comparing the likeness of The Last Of Us’s Elle character to Hollywood actress Ellen Page ever since the original reveal trailer. Well recently Ellen Page was part of a reddit Ask Me Anything thread and was asked to comment on Naughty Dog apparently drawing from her own likeness and putting it into the character of Ellie.

Read Full Story >>
relyonhorror.com
Cam9773951d ago

The similarity is shocking! It's like ND copied off Ellen directly, however, I'll let this slide as TLOU was a flipping masterpiece.

xHeavYx3951d ago

Ellie looked a lot more similar when they first announced TLOU, then Beyond was announced and ND changed Ellie a bit

badboy7763951d ago

1.She's just trying to get Paid.

2.Or she's just jealous that Ashley Johnson got the job over her.

Dead_Cell3951d ago

If she's trying to get paid she's got a good footing to go off of, as if ND used her likeness to such a level without their consent they can expect a bloody big lawsuit.

Dunpeal3951d ago

totally agreed. they did change her to look more like ashley johnson. you can see the resemblance, puckered lips and all

BISHOP-BRASIL3951d ago

Actually, I've been wondering for quite some time if they ever tried to get Ellen Page to voice Ellie and she declines as already working on another game, only to later be revealed it was Beyond, and yeah, they decided to change her and came up with younger Ellie, that would be totally funny and awkward!

-Alpha3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

^ She's not "trying to get paid", she was simply answering a question from Reddit, it's evident that many people think Ellen actually played Ellie.

Dee_913951d ago

I dont think she overreacted .. I think the responses are though

Ezz20133951d ago

when i saw the headline
i thought that was big deal

then i saw her comments on Reddit
she was chill and very cool
and not mad at all
and also the fact that she is getting paid from sony on making another ps3 exclusive

nothing to see here for me

Winter47th3951d ago

If Ellie was Ellen Page I wouldn't might letting the clickers eat her. She's SO.ANNOYING.

eyeDEVOUR3951d ago

Your exactly right...the first announcements of the game was a complete Replica of her...they've slowly changed it tho

pixelsword3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

Heh, I don't even know who she is, but calling the character "Elle" ain't helping...

Mutant-Spud3951d ago

Bah! Elle looks more like my 14 year old daughter Josie than she does 26 year old Ellen Page, Naughty Dog you may send my royalty cheques to....

SITH3951d ago

Trying to get paid? She has a net worth of 14 million. If anything naughty dog owes her because they clearly ripped her likeness. http://www.celebritynetwort...

KingKevo3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

Neil Druckmann (the Creative Director of TLoU) even said that they didn't see similarities but when people said they saw them they changed Ellie's character a lot for Ellie to be even more like Ashley Johnson (the actress who portrays Ellie).

I'm referencing this podcast btw (it contains heavy SPOILERS): http://epdaily.tv/all/type-...
Listen to it from 33:40.

Azurite3951d ago

Ellie was changed months before Beyond: Two Souls was announced at E3 2012.

zeee3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

Aham! No comments :)

k2d3951d ago

*Brings popcorn*

I love how this is being blown out of proportion, lol!

Ellen Page learned something new about the Internet today.. >:D

Ju3951d ago

I think that's a little bit of a weird reaction from Ellen Page. She could simply have said it's not her. Being in a video game she must have known that somebody else was mo-caped for that role. And instead she put attention onto her own character instead of giving Ashley (the real actress) the credit she deserves for playing the 14 year old Elle. Well played Page.

superkidcupid133950d ago

they both look the same
both have almost the same name
both act amazingly...but when TLOU and B2S was first announced i thought ellen was in both games...shaaaahhh-keeeeer....

Braid3950d ago

I'm sorry, I LOVE Last of Us. It's the defining game of the current gaming generation, no doubt about that.

But whoever thinks that Ellie from LoU does NOT look like Ellen Page is either completely blind or... partially blind.

justastranger103950d ago

Sony and Naughty Dog should compensate ellen Paige for this instead of trying to rip her off.

N4g_null3950d ago

Welcome to the movies. Better start selling box office tickets.

bigrob9043950d ago

yea at first it was an exact replica, but they changed it after beyond two souls was announced. now she doesn't look like her so i don't see the problem.

user55757083950d ago

lol yea...cause she would be all smiley and cute in a post apocalyptic world

+ Show (21) more repliesLast reply 3950d ago
Mr_Nuts3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

If you've seen Super with her in, the similarities between Ellie and Ellen are more noticeable

She had her moments in the film which seemed like something Ellie would do....except the parts in the film where she went all psycho when killing someone

http://www.youtube.com/watc...

ZodTheRipper3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

Ellie really could be a young Ellen Page, the similarities are pretty obvious. But I don't think that ND have taken her as a model while creating Ellie... if they did, they really did a great job bringing her character to life in TLOU.

ginsunuva3951d ago

Watch Juno.

Ellie and Ellen have almost the exact same clothing, hair, and most importantly, the confident, swearing, witty character that is almost identical!

thezeldadoth3951d ago

obviously they used her likeness. when beyond two souls was announced they went back and changed her to look less like ellen page. plus, ellie...ellen...ellie....ellen

Parapraxis3950d ago

How idiotic are the people who disagreed. This is LITERALLY where she said it.

PurpHerbison3951d ago

ND could be ripping off of any young white girl.

Temporary3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

someone said it. ^^^ whats the big deal again...?

DAS6923951d ago

Dakota Fanning says hey. ;)

fr0sty3951d ago

It not only looks like her, they even used an altered version of her name. They likely wanted her to be involved but Quantic Dream's role probably interested her more. Just speculation.

Persistantthug3950d ago (Edited 3950d ago )

Probably.

I mean, even though Naughty Dog has a higher pedigree than Quantic Dream....Quantic Dream sort of specializes in that Mo Cap stuff, and even has a movie credit to their name.

So I can see how/why she might be more interested in doing Beyond with QD more than TLOU with ND.

wastedcells3951d ago

Personally I don't care. Never crossed my mind as I was playing. I'm sure there is a Joel look alike out there somewhere too.

Just finished TLOU and its one of the best games ever made. Every gamer needs to play this game at some point. Hope they do a PS 4 remake for the Xbox fans switching over next gen. Or use the cloud to make it playable on ps4.

Picnic3950d ago

You don't care but no-one should care that you don't care! It's not you whose very similar likeness has been used! Such similarities are unlikely to be entirely accidental when you're talking about a videogames studio who will relatively savvy on the film stars of today.

rainslacker3951d ago

Ellen Page looks a lot like many other girls out there. There really isn't much to her appearance that stands out. This was even more true when she was Ellie's age. Ellie in TLOU looks like a typical teen girl.

This is kind of true of most children around Ellie's age. It isn't until a bit later in life when truly defining features stand out more.

Although, I will admit that the similarities are there.

CommonSense3951d ago

It was hardly a masterpiece. And it's not a surprise that they ripped off her likeness, they rip everything off. Their entire this-gen lineup was a series of cliches and been-there-done-thats.

There is just a group of people that want to believe ND are great developers, and therefore they shower praise on everything they make...even before they play it.

ASBO-53951d ago

Awww, does someone need a cookie? Or maybe its just that someones mommy & daddy didn't buy him a PS3 and is sour about never getting to play the best this gen has to offer.

fr0sty3951d ago

Yeah, that "group" of people must be quite large, considering their games were among the most critically acclaimed of the generation.

trouble_bubble3951d ago

@commonsense
Whoa. At ease soldier. A collection of your recent quotes:

"It is mind boggling how immature and hypocritical most of you are"

"The garbage double standard expressed by the community on N4G never gets old"

"Where do people come up with this trash? Stop being perpetually 6 years old"

"THIS is the intelligence level of the average Sony drone."

"This is why N4G is such a joke now. You people spout the dumbest stuff without researching anything"

"You people are so pathetic. Corporate worship is despicable"

"All these idiots have to do is say "sony" or "playstation" and the rest of you idiots "agree" and +bubbles. "

So angryz1! Jeremy spoke in class today?

irepbtown3950d ago

Well, if receiving 10/10's from the likes of Edge is being a rip off, I wan't to know what you regard to as a 'Masterpiece'...

Call of Duty? Fifa?

monkey nuts3950d ago

Common sense is not so common.

CommonSense3950d ago

There isn't a single reply to my comment that wasn't completely predictable.

I'd just like to point out that GTA4 was a HUGE game in terms of ratings...but i'll bet a least half of you don't think it deserved those accolades. I don't know why the industry has a love affair with certain developers...i accept that they do...doesn't mean it's going to manipulate my perspective. They do the same thing with games made by Ken Levine. They do it with a few developers.

Also, I don't think too many games are masterpieces. Half Life 2 comes to mind. The original StarCraft. Red Dead Redemption was pretty incredible. The first Portal was also pretty damn good. I'm sure there are others, but trying to make a point on n4g that goes against sony (and especially ND) is like trying to discuss economics with liberals, it is utterly pointless. which is why non-sony fanboys have migrated away from N4G and are now on reddit and 4chan.

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 3950d ago
showtimefolks3951d ago

When game was announced she was in it basically but than ND changed it

TLOU is a masterpiece

mrmarx3951d ago

she didnt get any money for it thats the issue

GribbleGrunger3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

If Naughty Dog have characters in The Last Of Us that look NOTHING like the actor that played them (Joel for instance), why on earth would they deliberately make a character look like Ellen Page? It doesn't make sense. ND design characters to look right for the part. I don't even think that the character in the game looks like Ellen Page at all, but I will concede that Ellen Page has quite a generic face and that a lot of Hollywood stars look similar to her.

Are you telling me you would confuse these two people:

https://encrypted-tbn1.gsta...

matgrowcott3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

It doesn't matter how similar you personally find them. By law, all that it matters is that people think that she's in it.

And you only need to look at that Reddit AMA to see that there are people that up until yesterday thought that Ellen Page was in The Last of Us.

I don't think she'll sue Sony/Naughty Dog - she wouldn't want to complicate things with Beyond, I guess - but if she did it'd be open and shut.

3950d ago
aquamala3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

old promo pics look just like her. less so after the re-design

http://www.eurogamer.net/ar...

HarryMasonHerpderp3950d ago (Edited 3950d ago )

Yeah I don't see the problem here since Naughty Dog changed the look of Ellie quite a while back. If they had stuck with the original design then fair enough but they didn't.
sooo?

x5exotic3951d ago Show
ChrisW3951d ago

@Cam977

You'd let it slide because it's a Sony Exclusive...

redcar1213951d ago

it is her she needs to sue them

stage883950d ago

I think it didn't help that Ellie was quite quirky eg. the jokes and was also quite tomboyish which fits Ellen Paige's characteristics.

BallsEye3950d ago

noticed it first time I saw the gameplay.

Gardenia3950d ago

It is pretty obvious that she was an inspiration for the character, not only the looks but her attitude as well. Also after Beyond's first reveal, Naughty Dog changed Ellie's looks because she looked too much like Jodie

GDDR6_20143950d ago

She's not in the credits? That's crazy

shadowst173950d ago

Most artists who model take reference from real people, Ellen page would probably be a good reference for how they wanted Ellie to look like, of course the artist won't right out copy Ellen Page's look but definitely incorporate elements of her.

RedHawkX3950d ago

i want to kiss ellen paige she looks cute cant wait for beyond 2 souls.

+ Show (20) more repliesLast reply 3950d ago
ifritAlkhemyst3951d ago

What's the big deal. I'd be flattered. But celebrities often don't think like that. Everything comes at a price with them, even compliments.

SegaGamer3951d ago

Exactly, i don't get why celebs need to make a big deal out of everything.

admiralvic3951d ago

Considering people pointing out how similar they looked since the first trailer and how the names are fairly similar, it's not that shocking. While it might be flattering in this setting, if I was someone of note I wouldn't let just anyone do whatever with my likeness.

Also lets be fair here, it also comes off as fairly lazy.

ifritAlkhemyst3951d ago

I don't understand why it's lazy. They saw inspiration in Ellen Page and so modeled Ellie after her, even going so far as to give her a similar name.

sway_z3951d ago

I wish there was an outbreak of intelligence to cure the dumb people that visit this site :)

ZombieNinjaPanda3951d ago

@ifritAlk;aljkd;fa

It's lazy and illegal to use someone's likeness without their consent. I'm not saying that's what happened here, but I'm just saying.

Erimgard3951d ago

It's like she said...she cares because she's actually lending her voice, likeness, and motion captured facial animations to another video game (Beyond: Two Souls), as part of a contracted agreement in which they approached her for permission. They did it the 'right' way, and she doesn't want another game stealing its thunder without even asking.

TXIDarkAvenger3951d ago

The thing is, I'm assuming she wants to be recognized for staring in the game Beyond Two Souls instead of Last of Us which she was not apart of.

DarthJay3951d ago

The big deal is that companies are trying to make money off of their likeness. Their product is their image. Themselves. They have every right to be upset. If someone wanted to draw a picture of them and hang it on a wall, that is a compliment. Drawing the picture and mass producing it for sale is a different animal all together.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 3951d ago
SpiralTear3951d ago

Why is she complaining? It's not like she's not going to be in another game on the same console in the next few months.

TXIDarkAvenger3951d ago (Edited 3951d ago )

She seems cool about it, so obviously she's not angry. She just wants to be recognized for a game she is staring in which Beyond: Two Souls.

Karpetburnz3951d ago

It's not really a big deal, but I would probably be annoyed if everyone thought I played a character when I didn't. Ellie did look a lot like Ellen page in the first trailer but they did change her a little. When I played through the game I never thought of Ellen. IMO Ellie has her own look about her. And you can tell she's a lot younger.

shadowst173950d ago

Shes not complaining, people are just exaggerating her comment to sound like she was trying to take a stab at naughty dog to the stage she would sue. It doesn't help that a bunch of trolls keep tweeting her saying how they loved her in Last of us.

Show all comments (251)
90°

The Sounds of the Fireflies ("The Last of Us") concert kicks-off on April 28th, 2024

"The Game Music Foundation are today very proud and pleased to announce an additional concert, circling back to the roots of Game Muisic Festival in Poland. On April 28th, 2024, the National Forum of Music in Wroclaw will once again become a place to celebrate the art of video game music, featuring scores from The Last of Us and The Last of Us Part II." - The Game Music Foundation.

430°

Naughty Dog’s Next Game Is “Really Ambitious” And Will Be “Really Hard” To Create

Speaking on what’s coming next for Naughty Dog, which could be either their new IP or The Last Of Us Part III, Druckmann gave what he seems to feel are realities of the project he’s talking about. That it’ll both be “really ambitious” but also “really hard.”

H943d ago

"I’ve really surrendered to knowing it’s going to be really hard, knowing it’s going to stress members of the team out"
As if crunch wasn't stressing them enough

helicoptergirl43d ago

Members of the team don't have to crunch anymore

helicoptergirl43d ago

According to people who work there

H943d ago

So the people who remained in a studio that had tons of workers quiting and others laid off said that they don't have to crunch, and you are just believing that

frostypants43d ago (Edited 43d ago )

They absolutely will wind up having to crunch. Happens at the end of almost every software project development cycle, especially with release date pressures. It's part of the job. Obviously they aren't in a crunch when they aren't in that late phase. But it's wishful thinking if they think they won't see that stress again. Druckmann himself seems to be aware of that.

helicoptergirl43d ago (Edited 43d ago )

Yes I believe them. The people who want to crunch can do it. The people who mentally and physically can't, don't actually have to. Some have young babies at home. Things have changed since the Schreier report.

rlow143d ago (Edited 43d ago )

@helicoptergirl
It wishful thinking to think some workers can choose to crunch or not to do so. That’s akin to people you work with saying they don’t have to do work they don’t like and you’re the one that has to take up the slack. That’s not how things work. Especially if your the person assigned to a specific task that has to be completed for the development to move forward. It’s a team sport when it comes to making a game. As with most things in life. Now that they are a smaller group, it’s even more important for everyone to pull their weight. Peace

helicoptergirl42d ago

@rlow that was exactly the mentality before the exposure and it was talked about and reported on. It's different now. You know, sometimes things and attitudes just change for the better. They knew they needed to change and they have and they're not stopping trying to make the creative environment as good as it can be.

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 42d ago
Tristan198243d ago

When someone pays another person to do a specific job in exchange for a certain rate of pay, it's called work.

H943d ago

They didn't sign to crunch and neither were they paid for it, people were hospitalized in Naughty Dog

MatrixxGT43d ago (Edited 43d ago )

Exactly most of these people wouldn’t last a season in the trades.

-Foxtrot43d ago

I f******* love how many people are doing a complete 180 on their views of crunch culture despite the awful stories reported on over the many years just because we’re talking about NaughtyDog

You can’t just cherry pick what to be mad about

“They signed a contract…it’s called work…that’s life…it’s a job”

I mean really guys, if this was EA you’d be having a field day

I bet you any money if any of these guys regardless of studio went in and said to their superior “Listen, don’t feel like the over time tonight, I’ll just stick to my normal contracted hours if that’s alright” I highly doubt they’d be given a warm response

Crows9043d ago

@h9

Actually yes they did. If overtime is mentioned...that's crunch.

Christopher43d ago

@Tristan1982: The problem is crunch is because of the inefficient management and sudden changes in projects. ND made major story changes based on some feedback, that results in months of rework, redesign, etc. And none of those changes were built into the project from the get-go, so they still have to meet a deadline.

@H9: One person. And they did sign up for crunch, ND is notorious for hiring people who don't mind it. That's the problem, they tell you who they are, people just aren't listening. And, they did get paid, just their QA level of people are paid shit, which is an industry issue for something so freaking important. And people wonder why we have such broken games at launch. Because companies don't want to pay to deliver as long as people will buy enough to get them past first few months of patches and then re-release a major patch with an expansion to get people to come back.

@-Foxtrot " You can’t just cherry pick what to be mad about " -- N4G home of 'hold my beer' on that alone.

CantThinkOfAUsername43d ago

The kindda guy to guilt trip others into overwork or tell them to be better slaves ('employees'). Exactly what corps like. How does it taste?

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 43d ago
anast43d ago

They get paid and they signed the contract. It's not a slave factory.

Shane Kim43d ago

Shh... your in the era of feeling sorry for people.

jwillj2k443d ago (Edited 43d ago )

Assuming you have a job, how would you feel working 80 hours a week for the same pay? You’ve not experienced crunch otherwise you wouldn’t be speaking like this.

senorfartcushion43d ago

As somebody who has crunched before. No, it wasn't my choice, no, you couldn't handle it, and no, you don't work in a better industry than I do.

Markusb3342d ago

exactly, get the game out before PS6 and if it takes crunch, or over time which you get paid for, get on with it

anast42d ago

"Assuming you have a job"

Assuming I haven't worked more for less, I suppose. And yes, I do.

"Shh... your in the era of feeling sorry for people."

I feel awful for the people that fought for the workers and got stuck holding the bag and lost everything.

"no, you couldn't handle it, "

You mean "I"

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 42d ago
Christopher43d ago

I really hope this isn't management BS stress. I get wanting to put the best out, finding the best new ways and concepts, and ensuring your design is just top notch and not wasteful and fulfilling, but when I hear some manager talking about this my first thought is "Are these jerks changing paradigms on a regular basis that's making people play catch up and redo work to meet their new goals?"

43d ago
Kiryu199243d ago

They lost so many great experienced talented people over the past 5 years

anast42d ago

Burnout is real. I even had to change my job because of it.

Markusb3342d ago

as if you dont get paid for crunch, get on with it,

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 42d ago
Stuart575643d ago

That it’ll both be “really ambitious” but also “really hard.”

Not 'is' but 'will be', kinda suggests that they haven't started yet, hope not.

Come on ND, a game PLEAAAAASSSSEEEE. Desperate this gen.

S2Killinit43d ago (Edited 43d ago )

From the article:

“Working on this new game, it’s really ambitious, parts of it are really hard,…”

That is the actual quote. They are already working on it.

LucasRuinedChildhood43d ago (Edited 43d ago )

Yeah, a lot of people push fake narratives about NaughtyDog and misquote things. That quote is very straightforward.

https://twitter.com/MitchyD...
Above is the complete debunking of a false story that still gets spread around all the time. And the bad faith actors doing it also only pin it on Druckmann for some reason and ignore Straley. They want to portray Druckmann as an evil schemer, even when the false story they're spreading doesn't align with their narrative. They don't care about reality ...

SuckerPunch doesn't get even 1% of this criticism and they haven't provided any update whatsoever on their next game, and it's a sequel not a new IP, so turnaround would be quicker. That's not logical.

Markusb3342d ago

probably 7 years out at this point after wasting all that time on factions

Stuart575643d ago

Also, just off-topic slightly but..

Does anyone think that layoffs now may well be making space for AI integration of game development, and 'crunch-time', 'unsustainable', 'big budget' are all terms been used to butter us up to receiving the news that AI integration will help and maintain the level of AAA games that were accustomed to? Perhaps the layoffs were the devs that didn't join a union quick enough and if only they had the smarts of SAG members and strike while the time is right, before its too late?! Imagine DEV's on strike at a time like this, there's already a game drought.

isarai43d ago

Nah, quite literally every industry around is having layoffs.

shinoff218343d ago

I work in manufacturing. Layoffs here to. Especially people with no skill. I feel bad for them more then anything.

isarai43d ago (Edited 43d ago )

I work in advertisement, Im being laid off in may despite being the 3rd best on my team of 15 just under the team lead and assistant team lead, and the assistant team lead is out next week. Yet the last two years we've all been congratulated for record numbers. Times are weird.

shinoff218343d ago

Game drought. Lol what. I can't keep up. There's so many dope games releasing. I gotta ask what do you play

Stuart575642d ago

Not Naughty Dog games, not this gen. You know, Naughty Dog? Who the article is about?

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 42d ago
Brazz43d ago

I hope they remember to make it realy fun to play.

FunAndGun42d ago

I hope it's extra woke and really fun to play.

Kneetos43d ago

And then Sony will lay off 900 more staff to save costs

Christopher43d ago

Is this supposed to be a big gotcha after Microsoft laid off 1,900 and we're ignoring that? Let alone the over 16,000 other layoffs from Microsoft in 2023?

Kneetos43d ago

This is an article talking about Sony, no one said anything about Microsoft

And we should always be reminded of it like people are doing with Microsoft, Sony shouldn't get a free pass either

Christopher43d ago (Edited 43d ago )

Yes, and this article is 100% about Sony firing people.

ND says new game is ambitious - until Sony lays off 900 more staff to save costs!
Sony publishes new gameplay video - until Sony lays off 900 more staff to save costs!
Sony announces weekend sale deals - until Sony lays off 900 more staff to save costs!

Show all comments (87)
150°

You almost got a version of The Last of Us 2 inspired by Bloodborne

A new The Last of Us 2 documentary reveals that Naughty Dog almost made a different version of the PS4 and PS5 game similar to Bloodborne.

Read Full Story >>
theloadout.com
Scissorman73d ago

Just make a new IP with the same concept. :)

toxic-inferno73d ago

Or just release a remaster of Bloodborne 😛

rippermcrip73d ago

Kind of a misleading comparison. They were simply talking about the game being melee oriented and more of an open world. I wouldn't compare a game to a soulslike based on that.

toxic-inferno73d ago

Open world in a very specific sense though. The sense of exploration and discovering shortcuts within a large, challenging area would feel great in a survival game like TLOU. But I'm sceptical it would be nearly as satisfying without the bonfire/lantern respawn system.

Inverno73d ago

A more melee oriented Last of Us 2 would've been so much better imo. The combat mechanics barely got any use from me cause everyone just shoots at you, and then the Scars with their bows are even more annoying. Level design was also more Bloodborne, and I love the level design in Souls game, there's a real sense of scale and exploration due to the branching paths. We really gotta move away from open world in the style of GTA and BoTW and do it more like Souls.

toxic-inferno73d ago

Completely agree with your final comment. Semi-linear open worlds like those in soulslikes are by far the most satisfying. Even Elden Ring (which is of course amazing) loses some of its heart due to it's open world.

72d ago
toxic-inferno72d ago

@SnarkyDoggy

Of course, my comment was my opinion, and may be different to yours.

I completely agree that Elden Ring's world is incredible. The design of every inch of its map is fantastic, with so much care that has been put into its layout and design to tell a story in the classic ambiguous way that FromSoft always manage. I would argue with anybody, any day of the week, that there is no finer example of open world design anywhere in gaming across all platforms and genres.

However, the 'heart' that I speak of is perhaps more aligned with gameplay. The more linear form of the previous games provides a distinct level of focus and determination that Elden Ring lacks due to the nature of it's open world. In Dark Souls, Bloodborne, etc. you often have between one and three bosses available to you at any time, requiring dedication and a certain level of grit. You have to learn each boss, master the techniques required and vanquish them before moving on. Between 60% and 90% of the bosses in each game generally result in this experience.

I had no such experience in Elden Ring, except for the fight against Malenia, because the nature of the open world meant that there was always something else to do and explore. The open world encouraged this, meaning that I spent most of the game over-levelled for the bosses I was facing. And I didn't even go out of my way to over-level.

To conclude, the heart of Soulsbourne games isn't inherently the difficult; it's the grit and determination required to beat them. There are other things that factor into the soulslike genre, but that gameplay loop is the real soul of the series. And Elden Ring, mostly due to it's open world, lacked that particular aspect.

As I have said, you are welcome to disagree with me! But I hope that further explains my original statement.

shinoff218373d ago

I don't think we need to move away from a gta open world style. There's room for all. I enjoy open and linear along with in between. If you have an issue I imagine it's on the devs.

Inverno73d ago

An in-between then should be considered more often. I'm just not a fan of the long stretches of land of nothing. Idk whatchu mean by the last thing tho, I like ND.

Demetrius73d ago

Def did good with their own thing I'm so over the whole copy souls combat sheesh I can dee if in certain games it would be bosses that looked like a souls boss but straight out copying the combat and feel takes away from a game that supposed to be its own lol

Show all comments (18)