220°

Pokémon X and Y Seem Rushed, Need More Polish

GenGAME writes: Pokémon has finally made the jump from the 2D realm of sprites to a fully 3D (in every sense of the word, given the stereoscopic functions of the 3DS) world. Is the dimensional upgrade the right move for the Pokémon franchise?

That depends on if it’s done right. The change gives Pokémon the ability to do new things, but Game Freak has to make sure they don’t rush the sixth generation and release an underachieving game experience.

disturbing_flame4119d ago

Rushed ? maybe not, maybe the game has just been developped for the DS and has been ported to 3DS

Erimgard4119d ago

That goes against what the developers have said.

Trunkz4118d ago (Edited 4118d ago )

How does it lack polish or even seen as a port? If they make it like any Pokemon game, it's going to be huge and have tons of content, you can't make it look like Vita, have 3D and have hundreds of PKMN with levels and towns.

Tei7774117d ago (Edited 4117d ago )

lol, why do I see this sentiment so often. People need to stop pretending that actual effort is put into these pokemon games and that their presentation shortfalls are a result of technical limitation. Yes, there are hundreds of pokemon to model and animate but pokemon are not detailed characters, nor is there movement highly realistic.

Look at Monster hunter freedom unite on the psp. It has 80 monster in it and every single one of them is many times more complex than even the most ambitious pokemon, boasting fluid animations and detailed texture maps. Alongside this they have their own AI and Behaviour. We're talking about a game on the PSP!

The truth is nintendo has never and probably never will give the pokemon games the budget they deserve and Gamefreak will probably never set their ambitions higher then the absolute minimal.

TruthbeTold4118d ago

If anything was perhaps rushed, then it would be the assets that they used for the incomplete build of the game used for the trailer.

The game doesn't release until October. That's over 8 months of finishing and polishing time before production starts. I don't see what the issue is here...

KingWilly1054118d ago

I don't think it's fair to say the game is unpolished yet; the game isn't out yet, it's in the process of being polished right now.

zerocrossing4118d ago

Yeah the last 10% of game design is polish, best not judge the graphical aspects of it till closer to release.

Blastoise4118d ago

True. They've got the best part of a year to get this game finished

Mainsqueeze4118d ago

Yeah i honestly don't see how you can call this game rushed yet when we have literally only seen a 2 min trailer and its still got almost a year more of dev time.

overrated444118d ago

So based on this article it should be assumed that the author has already played the game, which is impossible. Speculation post, I'll pass.

Erimgard4118d ago

The article is about graphics. Which can be seen in the trailers.

Hicken4118d ago

Isn't it STILL too early?

Outside_ofthe_Box4118d ago (Edited 4118d ago )

There is plenty of time for them to polish up the graphics. To say a game seems rushed and needs more polish 9 months before it's even out is ridiculous. I mean, what do you expect they'll being doing from now to release? Twiddling their thumbs?

khowat4118d ago

Yeah, I see where the author is coming from but then again the Pokemon series JUST got 3D graphics. Of course it doens't make effective use of the 3ds's capabilities but then again it's Pokemon, graphics aren't and never will be what makes it great. Black and white 2 which was pretty much black and white was the 4th highest selling game of 2012 right behind black ops 2 and Halo 4. I have very few doubts that this pokemon game could do any worse that 6 million copies...

GlaceEx4118d ago

it does take advantage of the 3ds's full capabilities just not yet... on the official pokemon website it even says that on the pokemon x an y page at the bottom... and they increased the graphics abit with B2W2, but they were on the same system so it had hard to change the graphics more... and i am sure pokemon x and y will be the best selling games of the year... i know people who hated every generation of pokemon after the originals who want these games and some people who have hated pokemon in general who want them...

BlackWolf4118d ago

I don't know... It's too early to judge it. I thinks the graphics level, in comparison to Pokedex 3D and MD 3DS, is because the Pokemon RPG system needs to play in real time (loading time-wise). Again, it's still in development, so there's still room for improvements, but it doesn't look rushed to me.

Show all comments (33)
70°

The Best Games Similar to Pokemon for PlayStation

There are many worlds out there brimming with wondrous creatures ready to help you on your adventure beyond Pokemon.

Read Full Story >>
powerupgaming.co.uk
LG_Fox_Brazil31d ago

Temtem is actually really good as a single player experience or as a co-op game. Played the shit out of it when it released

60°

Pokémon Gen 10 Release Date Predictions: Are New Pokémon Games In 2024?

Even if Pokémon Scarlet and Violet have not yet completed their first anniversary, it is possible to predict exactly when Gen 10 is arriving.

Read Full Story >>
screenrant.com
160°

Pokemon Doesn't Need to Sue Palworld, It Needs to Get With the Times

The Nerd Stash: "There's been a lot of talk about Pokemon and Palworld recently, but if anything, Pokemon's new competition should be a sign to change."

Read Full Story >>
thenerdstash.com
ChasterMies83d ago

Fortunately for Nintendo, the legal team is separate from Game Freak’s development team.

NotoriousWhiz83d ago

Unfortunately for us, as their legal team seems to be more competent than Game Freak's development team.

gold_drake83d ago (Edited 83d ago )

they do tho .. IF there is something to sue for. IP infringement is such a delicate thing.

but absolutely agree on the change

GoodGuy0983d ago

That, have longer dev time, and absolutely get rid of Nintendo as the exclusive platform. Imagine a AAA pkmn game on current consoles or next generation.

But money, they'll make billions with little effort.

badz14983d ago

you know that's never gonna happen

FinalFantasyFanatic83d ago

Gamer Freak, Creatures and Nintendo all have a stake in the Pokemon franchise, Nintendo especially will never let them go, I don't know how Creatures or Game Freak feels about it. Plus, the other two don't have a financial incentive to ditch Nintendo, they make mega bucks regardless. Although I think Nintendo should help Game Freak out more since they're clearly struggling, other they'll all just have to accept longer dev times and bigger gaps between games, or maybe just make some cheaper low-tier games in-between.

shinoff218383d ago

Idk yall. I'd take a Pokémon jrpg over a Pokémon with guns, online play etc. Plus wasn't Pokémon mobile pretty fking big like 4 years ago then covid hit.

--Onilink--83d ago (Edited 83d ago )

Even Scarlet/Violet had sold 24million as of early November (and undoubtedly sold even more during the Holidays), its not like they are currently suffering.

Yes, there are plenty of things I would like Gamefreak to do better, and yes I happened to like Palworld, but not because its a Pokemon clone, because its not, but because its a good survival game, something that I have zero interest for the mainline Pokemon games to become.

Most publications keep bringing up these topic ls just for clicks, because clearly the game is your typical survival game (most who do well on PC) with some Pokemon sprinkled in and not a Pokemon competitor, the core gameplay loop is clearly just Ark with dinosaurs swapped for Pokemon like creatures

And again, while I’m enjoying the game itself, I hope it doesnt set a new precedent for what we expect from game devs these days because, based on their other games, this developer really seems to basically just try to go as close as possible to ripping off other games without getting into trouble and then not really following up on those projects as promised (Craftopia players seem particularly angry).

I doubt they ever expected the discourse around this game to reach this level of popularity to push those insane sales numbers, and they actually take the opportunity to increase the quality of their work

FinalFantasyFanatic83d ago (Edited 83d ago )

I'm going to say something somewhat controversial, the last set of Pokemon games weren't that bad, it wasn't a great game, but a good game if we ignore the performance issues (and I personally didn't have many bugs).

They just need more interesting towns and NPCs (give them interesting dialogue, there's literally no reasons to talk to NPCs), interesting areas/locations (like the sunken ship and Bellsprout Tower), and some decent side quest, there isn't really any interesting side quests in those games, and fix the barely there lore for the game (Idk even know what was going on with those 4 "legendary Pokemon"). And maybe add less new Pokemon into the next game so they can transition more of the older Pokemon into 3D.

I think Scarlet/Violet had the potential to go from a good game to a great game if they implemented most of those ideas, but they also needed more development time to optimise the game as well.

Profchaos83d ago

Yeah agree id take a remake of red in the style of the links awakening remake any day of the week

Profchaos83d ago

No they don't I don't want any of the gameplay anywhere near Pokemon the only link between them is the idea of Pokemon except there's guns you enslave humans and Pokemon and there's a survival aspect.

Pokemon is fairly family friendly can't see Nintendo going ok let's give them m16s and slaughter each other

Show all comments (12)