Response To Gamers: Where the F@!* is Uncharted 2!?

MonsterVine.com staff editor Zack Chase writes, "...to guarantee success, the game has to play it safe. Thus, it sticks to concepts people know and are accustomed to. Uncharted 2 you won’t find ANY creativity. What you’ll see is emulation and refining."

[gravemaker]

screw you, uncharted 2 is not overrated

[creatchee]

The only thing that COULD be overrated is the multiplayer. It was fun, but didn't really last for me.

Single player is a different story - it's in my top 3 of all-time single player games.

This grasps at straws.

[TEFL0N_D0N_81]

I liked Uncharted 2 because they brought in another great story, and took away some bad gameplay (that grenade tossing arc using the six-axis in Uncharted 1 had to definitely go).

What I don't like about Uncharted 2 (and no game can be perfect) is the shooting mode. It's not accurate enough, and the damage is a bit inconsistent. Cover system was (and is) good. By the way, I hated the same thing about Uncharted 1, but still loved the game.

[blahblah]

I couldn't stop playing it. Version that came with game... meh... not to say they completely destroyed it with tweaking.

While I was playing beta at least 50% of its time. I only went online few times with official. Somehow it didn't feel quite right.

As far as UC2 goes, I was kinda meh, except for graphics which rock like nothing before. UC1 had better feel. Better enemies. Better plot. If you played UC1, UC2 story was far too predictable, same twists at the same time. And very overrated enemies instead of really good fights in UC1.

UC1 is my 2nd favorite game after Demon's souls and before MGS4, UC2 is far, far behind on that list.

[HolyOrangeCows]

One of the best games of this generation. Cry 'bout it.

"Uncharted 2′s main problem is that it just tries too hard to be a money making franchise. Yes, it succeeds in that aspect, but only because the general audience is full of easy to please tools who crave a new desert to pop some heads in"
Where are his "_____ is overrated" articles for Halo, Call of Duty, etc?

Besides, Uncharted 2 was FAAAAAAAAR from just "a new desert to pop some heads in"

[theballa113092]

Holy CRAP did he actually say that? Wow. I'm not even going to bother to read it. Seriously. A Money Making Franchise?

[Heisenberg]

If any game deserves the hype and kudos it's U2. Give credit where credit's due. No matter how good something is, there'll always be an obscure angry nerd blogger who needs hits to hate on it.

[BYE]

I gotta agree it is a little bit overrated.

Demon's Souls should have gotten more attention in 2009, it has a lot more depth.

[Darkfocus]

Demons souls's was my GOTY 2009. uncharted was great in every aspect but demons souls had far better gameplay to the extent that it made up for all it's other flaws.

[Chuk_Chuk]

seems like this guy has had a low hit count.

As for Uncharted 2. Words can't even begin to describe how amazing that game is.

[xTruthx]

@Blacktric

I don't think N4g users where the ones who gave the game over 200 awards

[raztad]

"Uncharted 2 you won’t find ANY creativity. What you’ll see is emulation and refining"

A very dumb thing to say. UC2 integration of cinematic, platforming, puzzles made it one of the leading games in the industry. Ask Enslaved devels.

[mantisimo]

.....But I have personally never invested more time or enjoyed more time with any game, EVER and I have been a gamer since pong.

[moparful99]

Here's my take on it, From the second uncharted 2 began to play until the closing scene my jaw was permanantly unhinged. I couldn't believe just how excellent the whole experience was. From the eye bleeding graphics, Best voice acting i've ever heard, witty dialogue, creative levels, and over the top set pieces I just couldnt find anything wrong with the game. At times there were some frustrating elements that would piss me off but as soon as I figured out how to beat them I had a great sense of accomplishment. This author just strikes me as one of those people that refuses to give it credit because of all the hype and praise it recieved. I thoroughly enjoyed the game, matter of fact I've beaten it on every diffculty and just the other day replayed on hard.. This game is in my top 10 of all time..

[J-Smith]

uncharted 2 is a MASTERPIECE

come on i thought n4g.com was going to move on from these articles with its new look & that.
its the same old sh*t, different day on this

[Cyorg]

The fact that people are still talking about this game proves that it's not overrated.

[gunnerforlife]

about overrated kmmmtt

i jst started playing it again from the beginning and i still love it as much as i did playing it my first time!

[N4BmpS]

Okay Let me get this straight, based on what he wrote. He made a list of his favorite games this generation, Uncharted 2 was not on his list and people, well ridiculed or insulted him. I'm right so far, correct? I thought so, let's continue on. He decides to "revisit" Uncharted 2 by playing his favorite chapters from the game(let me say that again. He, the author revisited his favorite chapters in the entire game). Okay I understand, moving on now.

Apparently, while playing the game he noticed somethings, that, I don't know he didn't notice before, the controls and cover system were laggy and clunky and well that did him a disservice as it would anyone. He tried to throw a propane tank to get some kills but it didn't work(understandable) he emptied 60 clips in a few baddies, it took a while for them to die which to me seems like he's implying that's not realistic enough (but Uncharted 2 isn't exactly based off of realism in terms of gameplay or gunplay more specifically) let's move on, he tries to melee and goes into cover... Hmmm he has a point (his first one so far) they cover system can be quite grabby sometimes I experienced this 2 whole times (big number right? TWO).

Okay, because I don't feel like talking about this, I'll get to my point, to me and I maybe mistaken but it seems that he was bitter and angry because he was insulted by some morons on the net. Congratulations whatever your name is, you've just experienced this space known as the internet, more specifically the gaming community, in case he never knew this, there is a lot of ignorance here and plenty to go around. So next time you want to call a game overrated make sure you're not doing it just to piss a few fanboys off. Okay? :)

[jerethdagryphon]

uncharteds damage system is best decribed as plot based,

if your up against 2 hard nuts who need to delay drake then they take mazillions of rounds to down or 4 headshots

if your beign swamped enmasses they die quick

[squallheart]

This article sounds like a gametrailers review. What was the reason for giving it a lower score, because it felt the same. I never seen that issue being brought up with gta, halo , mw etc

[BannedForNineYears]

Lol title change?
I clicked a link that said, "Look back review, and why Uncharted 2 is overrated".
And now it's "Response To Gamers: Where the F@!* is Uncharted 2!?".
There's quite a difference. -_-

[Ratchet_Co]

Uncharted 2 is not overrated. And what's this I hear about lack of originality? Yes, the game does carry a variety of gameplay mechanics from games like Gears and Tomb Raider. But unlike most games which rip off others Uncharted 2 introduced a better form of story-telling graphics, and gameplay through it's technical prowess. Not many games can pull off that now-famous train chapter which had enemies shooting, lush environments and a heli on steroids. The story-telling was so much more improved through graphics and animations because they made the characters and environments more believable.

I find it hilarious he finds the cover system janky.

"I began my venture by loading up the few select chapters that take place right after Drake gets out of prison and into the war-zone. Why? Because the beginning of a game is supposed to set up everything, both gameplay and story...it introduced movement rather than gunplay"

Of course you find the movement janky, you didn't even play the first part!

[Dark General]

Uncharted 2 is a good game. But for me it's not as good as the original Uncharted. I agree with some of this bloggers gripes about the game. I believe that the 2nd one simply put tried to hard to emulate big budget Summer holleywood flicks. While I really appreciate the effort, production values and incredible voice work it just didn't wow me. Gameplay wise Among Thieves really hit the game out the park with better mechanics, tougher puzzles and had very good pacing.

But story and character wise the game felt flat to me. I felt like I knew what was going to happen before it happened and the game was rife with refined cliches.In contrast to Drakes Fortune where I felt on the edge of my seat and didn't know what to expect from one moment to the next. The characters also seemed more lively and much less stereotypical (except maybe Eddie Rahja) and Elena one of the first great impressions of a strong female character.

In the end I think U2 is a great game which tried too hard to be like a big action movie while the original was like playing a great unique action movie. The original felt like it had more heart, specially story and character wise while it came up a little bit short in some aspects of gameplay. Opposed to Among Thieves which delivered great gameplay but was too cliched in my opinion. Either way I'm really looking forward to Uncharted 3 (Atlantis?) where Naughty Dog takes the best part of Among Thieves and Drakes Fortune and creates one of the all time greats.

[AliTheBrit19]

Yes, yes it is overrated

Oh jeez, it got all of those awards!?! well it must be amazing, I mean, those people gave it those awards!

...................

...........................

It's overrated, its a great game don't get me wrong, and one I will never boot out of my game collection, but the praise it got was ridiculous

It had no originality, nothing unique, just a standard third person action adventure.

[ia_studio]

I agree with the article U2 plays too safe, I was wondering why I didn't enjoy it that much.

[BornToKill]

you have to be a special kind of retarded fanboy to say uncharted 2 is overrated.

[BYE]

Bullshit. You can still have an own opinion as a PS3 user, there's no law saying that if you own a PS3, you have to like Uncharted 2.

I like it btw, but it's overrated. There are better games on PS3.

[inception123]

how can you say it is overrated when it has more awards then any game(over 150), one of the highest rated games, has sold over 3.5 mil and lots of devs are giving praise to saying it is the standard for games not just in it's genre but all games with the story telling, gameplay and graphics and are using it as their inspiration? just because you don't like means nothing since everyone else did meaning it isn't overrated it delivered.

[aaronisbla]

overrated would be something that was hyped to kingdom come, then fell short or far short of expectations.

Overrated does NOT mean its talked about way too much. And even if it did, most of the talk about UC2 on this site as of late is in the forms of negativity or comparing other games, particularly 360 games and multiplatform games don't really help. If it's overrated and someone is tired of hearing about the game, why waste time writing an article about unless the author is seeking hits?

[RedDead]

No overrated means it's gotten too many awards and perfect reviews than it deserved. Your thinking of overhyped.

[likedamaster]

I never knock Uncharted 2 so fanboys could have their moment. But you're right Ceekay, we're entitled to our own opinion.

Same thing applies with Gears of war, got many awards but some out there thought it was over rated and didn't enjoy it. Personally, U2 didn't have the same impact Uncharted 1 had on me, so I just coasted through. I also fell asleep in the first 30 minutes of it. True story.

[blahblah]

so... I have to be special kind of retarded fanboy to say that UC1 was better in almost every aspect than UC2 (UC2 is a perfect graphic jaw dropper)?

UC2 story was more or less timed twist copy of UC1. Same event at the same time, just different place, persons, monsters.

UC1 had much better fight layouts (one of best in game fights ever), UC2 is just more enemies which are harder to kill (I don't even wanna talk about retarded boss fights where you needed to shoot complete arsenal of small country to kill some boss, while UC1 had one of the best enemy swarmings ever instead of boss figths).

UC2 was forgettable in my book, UC1 last stages with monster swarming I expect to remember on my death bed as one of the most exhilarating experiences ever.

Only Demon's souls tops UC1 in my book.

[pustulio]

If this ever gets approved we all know a shitstorm will come...

PS3 fanboys please read the article before start saying stuff like gravemaker and things like "omfgz you are an idiout! uc is tha greatesttt sheet eva!!!1!!"

I don't think it's overrated but it's not the best game out there...

[BornToKill]

it was the best game of 2009!

[pustulio]

You said it OF 2009.

Not of all time.

If it's your favourite it's OK it's great but for me i had more fun with other games...

Sorry it's a matter of opinion. (:

[morganfell]

But your little worthless opinion is crushed and obliterated by an unbelievable volume of opposing opinions. The only person that needs to go off and stick their head in the dirt is you.

What you and a handful of people think is inconsequential to what the vast vast majority know. You and your two cronies are the ones that can't handle the truth, not the rest of the gaming world.

[jjohan35]

I don't think it's overrated but I also don't think it's the best game out there. That crown belongs to MGS4.

[HorsePowerr]

Uncharted 2 is a masterpiece.

[Dance]

overrated masterpiece that is

[LarVanian]

So you still think it is a masterpiece Dance? Lol I agree, it is a masterpiece!

[N4BmpS]

Yep you heard him, it's a masterpiece.

[GeoramA]

Uncharted 2 is not overrated.

Halo is overrated.

[MIDNIGHTMASK85]

Oh I wondered how long it would take until soneone mentioned Halo, you just cant help yourself can you, does the article compare it too Halo in anyway shape or form?....... No it doesn't so why bring Halo into this *yawn*

[ia_studio]

In my opinion both are overrated.
games that take chances and succeed are the ones that are worth the attention.

[Baltis]

Uncharted 2 is overrated. What with it's stellar usage of "Hey, give me a boost so I can kick this unconventionally placed crate down to you" In every level. Even the mountains are littered with this same, absurd, generic, gameplay.

Uncharted 2 was good, overall. But it was not great. And it in no way was better than Uncharted 1.

Edited for the puppet below me.

Yes, stupid because I liked and enjoyed the 1st Uncharted, obviously more than you did. Yeah, it's stupid to have your own mind and make up. Of course, I'm on a site full of robots and meat puppets. What was I thinking?

Edited for the other puppet below me.

Who said Uncharted 2 was bad? I didn't. I actually said it was good. Use some comprehension skills. Or polish up what little you have left. Yeah, the world needs less open to mediocrity people and more eyes wide shut people. That's the ticket. "rolls eyes"

And Uncharted 2 has to be good because pro magazines and websites said it is! That's funny. Ignorant bliss is what that is. When a game you all hate gets low scores it's ok. But when a game you love gets low scores the mag or site is always wrong. OR being paid off. This site is full of people like you I can see that now.

[BornToKill]

"Uncharted 2 was good, overall. But it was not great. And it in no way was better than Uncharted 1."

has to be the dumbest shiz i read all day.

says the guy that hates everything... you don't deserve to play video games. and uncharted 2 improved in almost EVERYTHING in the second game.

now go take a nap under your bridge troll.

[blahblah]

Improved in what exactly beside graphics which are fucking rocking?

Story was nothing that quickly redesigned UC1, if you played UC1... UC2 was predictable to the level of boring.
Fight layouts were much more thought out in UC1, arenas were smaller, but at the same time much better done (catacombs and last stages of UC1 are unforgettable). UC2 just had... many enemies.
Introducing boss fights? Lame... UC1 had much better aspect with enemy swarming on crucial plot twists.
UC1 on crushing still counts as one of the best experiences in my book (I still play that for the 7th time). UC2 I simply put down after I finished it for the first time and never took it out of the box again.

The only unforgettable things in UC2 are graphics which put down any game.

[LarVanian]

So just because Uncharted 2 had a certain cliche that popped up numerous times, made it a bad game? Nice logic man.

""But it was not great""

Mmm ok. Here is the cold hard truth, that is just your opinion. It is not fact. If it was fact then Uncharted 2 wouldn't have won more awards than any other game in 2009 and it wouldn't have gotten highly praised reviews.
I'm so glad that people like you don't review video-games, so glad.

[Johnny_Bravo]

All reviews and awards given out are people's opinions, none of them are facts. Uncharted 2 was not that great and IMO was an 8.5 at best, if you don't like my opinion well than that's your problem. You can list or say anything you wish to feel better about yourself but either way I'm going to think the game was good, but not that great.

[dustgavin]

IMO Uncharted 2 deserves every award that it has won and millions of gamers happen to agree that it is the top game of 2009.

[LarVanian]

@ Bravo
No offense man but I honestly don't give a crap about your opinion, so think and feel what you wish, because I am honestly not going to waste my time trying to change it.
The reason I replied to Baltis was because he gave what I thought was a stupid and weak reason as to why he didn't think the game wasn't anything special.
I think there are too many of these pointless "Uncharted 2 is overrated" articles. They honestly need to stop because they're not contributing anything other than some random guy's opinion (On a game that came out more than half a year ago)

PS- Quick question but I are you feeling ok today? Because you sounded quite bitter in your post :)

[Biggest]

The best part about your opinion on this matter, Johnny_Bravo, is that it matters to you alone. The world doesn't care what you think. The people that have a say have spoken. Naughty Dog's trophy cases show what they had to say.

[Poseidon]

if this article says uc2 is overrated then mario, zelda, gran turismo, resident evil, silent hill, mass effect, fallout, oblivion, gears of war, and grand theft auto are overrated. THIS GAME OWNS FACEPALM.

and i dont believe a thing you said, if you give me that, oh! i played it crap, im betting you just youtubed it.

[LarVanian]

So just because I made one little mistake I need comprehension skills? Once again, nice logic.
You still only used one factor to describe the game as generic and overrated, and that is why I am glad people like you do not review video-games, you would never give any fare reviews.
Uncharted 2 had a wide variety of gameplay, and yet you made it sound as if it had very few.

""This site is full of people like you I can see that now.""

Well if you don't like it, then get lost. :)

EDIT- I wonder who these little disagree trolls are that keep following me around. They can't seem to come out of the shadows and explain why they disagree with me lol

[playstation_clan]

take it away Beyonce

http://www.youtube.com/watc...

[BoneIdle]

I dont care if someone thinks its over rated or not but thi sarticle so so badly put together i had a lot of trouble even reading it like this line belwo what the hell does that even mean.

Quote from article "the general audience is full of easy to please tools who crave a new desert to pop some heads in" ???????

[mcz]

A game that wins 100+ awards, is seen as one the best games of this generation, and is used as a benchmark for graphics, storytelling etc can't be called overrated.

[SOAD]

Wouldn't that be precisely why it is overrated? Not that I think it's overrated but saying, "Hey, it's not overrated, just look at the score" is circular reasoning.

[Biggest]

But that line of thought would mean that is nothing deserving of praise. If you praise something, it becomes a new candidate for overration (new word). Overrated would be North Carolina basketball at the start of the 2009 season. Properly rated would be Duke at the end of the 2009 season. Uncharted 2 didn't only win pre-season awards. It delivered when it counted in the end as well. Uncharted 2 is the properly rated best game of 2009. Since there are only 20-30 years of such ratings, Uncharted 2 is also one of the best games of all time. The rating seems to fit.

[N4BmpS]

Well no just because it won so many awards and has so many accolades doesn't mean it's overrated. But yeah it is circular reasoning. My thought is that if Uncharted 2 was overrated then that would mean that the game was more like Wolfenstein than say a Portal or GTA 3.

People (fans) have it in their heads that Uncharted 2 is perfect and critics have stated that it's not perfect but it's a very firm step forward. The problem with saying it's perfect is you get articles like this from people who bitter and a bit bias towards the title. The end result is not good as you can see. Also some people don't understand the the word overrated properly.

[Poseidon]

GET OUT.

[KILLERAPP]

I’ll quote Adam Sessler on this, “Uncharted 2 is the greatest single player game I have ever played, period” and he has been reviewing games since 1998 on x-play, simple as that…

[saint_john_paul_ii]

yea, its overrated, thats why other companies uses it as a benchmark now on how to make a good game, right?

but MW2 gets the free pass, good job there journalist.

[SOAD]

Other companies always use other games as benchmarks because they copy successful games. Call of Duty is used as a benchmark for other shooters.

The media reception of Uncharted 2 was overwhelmingly positive, that's why other developers will use Uncharted 2 as a model for a great game.

But if someone believes that Uncharted 2 is overrated, you can't objectively invalidate their belief. If they played the game and didn't think it deserved 100+ GOTY awards, then that's their opinion.

[thebudgetgamer]

if you don't like a certain game that's fine, but when you start calling people tools for liking something you don't. you're an asshole.

[militant07]

its also vice-versa

you're an asshole if you call call people stupid or fanboys for not likeing

[thebudgetgamer]

i think he's an asshole because he is the type of person that thinks his opinions are gospel and if you don't think the same you must be stupid.

[TROLL EATER]

still a good rental game though

[Hazmat13]

your mom was a good rental. there i have joined the uncharted2 fight. now back to my Xbox. lol

[Mamajuana]

I've been playing games for over 20 years. Uncharted 2 is easily one of the greatest games I've played. At least top 3. That's just my opinion.

[darkziosj]

what have you done, oh well let the flames begging

[A change in the wind]

Lol, only on PS3, I know it eats you up inside. Keep crying, crybabies.

[LedZeppelin]

plethora....lol

[blasian]

Uncharted for ME personally was a very rewarding game that has set standards. Maybe it was not the best game of all time but it has taken a seat up there with the greatest.

[GodHandDee]

and why it's pathetic excuse for a website

[skip2mylou]

why wasnt this said about halo, call of duty, forza, gears of war?

PLUS THERE IS LIKE OVER 20 reports and it still passed approval wtf?

[Rampaged Death]

The best game I have ever played. Still better than anything that has come out this year.

[ATLGAMER]

Still a great game and relevant to the conversation...What happen to MAss Effect 2...thought it was so good but u hear nothing about it

[militant07]

you hear nothing? you obviously not following the game...

[Hyperguy20]

If this game has no creativity then whats MW2?

[militant07]

well, both are

[El-Fenemeno1213]

I revisit Uncharted 2 everyday, I can tell it doesn't suck, my opinion. Now i can make an article -_-

[Playerz8]

Wow this guy could not be more of a 360 fanboy. Uncharted 2 is definitely NOT overrated. In fact, it's a brilliant game and it controls better than half of all the games he talked about.

Plus he bashes on PSN like he lives in Xbox Live. Really, PSN is awesome.

[knightdarkbox]

38 m of ps3= Uncharted 2 is the most marketed game I've see and only sell only 3.0 M copies...

nuff said.

[Baka-akaB]

funny thing is your favorite game seems to a jrpg that was supposed to be the final fantasy killer , with huge hype surrounding a staff composed of FF's father figure , a big shot mangaka , etc .

Basically the dream team of jrpg , and it only did around 800k worldwide , most not even in japan , and wasnt even really a critics and review darling .

Everyone can play that silly game too ,
nuff said

[Thoreau]

xbox game as your avatar, so the tone of your comments may be slanted.

nuff said.

[Playerz8]

Great sales doesn't mean great game. Case in point: Wii Play. That sucked hard.

[likedamaster]

But a spectacular game is also synonymous with great sales. No?

[silvacrest]

actually, no

[MonopolyRSV]

Poorly written article.

[HumanStark]

Anyone who bitches about Uncharted 2 probably doesn't deserve to own video games.

[zatrox]

Uncharted 2 was a pretty great game, sure, but it WAS overrated.

[HumanStark]

Yeah, yeah, yeah, I'm all about calling out fanboy circle jerks, but what's a better game in 2009 than Uncharted 2? MW2? If you're complaining about Uncharted being unoriginal you should probably hate every new COD game to come out.

SF4? Okay. I know I've logged more hours as a World Warrior than in Uncharted, but it certainly didn't give me any engaging thrills like the adventure in U2.

Batman Arkham Asylum? Maybe.

Uncharted 2 is pretty much the bench mark for action games nowadays. You don't have to love the PS3 or the 360 to know that Naughty Dog put out an exemplary product that dominated the year.

[never_waste_a_bullet]

completely agree-> new benchmark in gaming, for its graphics, sound, gameplay, and online

[Baka-akaB]

just listen at yourself , if it was great , how it is overrated ? Doesnt great pretty much suffice to define it ? Or did i miss those "its the best game ever created in history" articles outnumbering those monthly "uc2 is overrated" articles and comments ?

[zatrox]

While I enjoyed the game alot, there were a few flaws on it.

There's no perfect game, being honest. Sheesh, just because I saw a few flaws on the game (I.E., not enough weapons, plot was a bad summerflick but greatly written, platforming controls sometimes didn't worked, etc.) I still enjoyed it.
Seriously, guys.

[gmoney0505]

Wow. Another article about Uncharted 2 being overrated.

Well I guess this guy is creative and has his own opinion about the game that no one has never said. Wait, it is the same thing that people who try to hate on all PS3 games said when the game first come out. This guy is being a follower and not having his own opinions about the game. He is doing the same exact article that haters been writing since the game came out which makes this article complete bullshit in its own rights.

[Baka-akaB]

The whole concept of the article from the title alone , was to nitpick and "porve" why it's overrated .

With that premise , is it even any wonder he indeed found it overrated ? With the added support of sheeps , who believes they are the cool rebels going against mainstream propaganda ...

Replace uncharted 2 by any XXX game with the same concept of article , and chances are it will be indeed "overrated".

Same place next year with another popular game to prove overrated on either 360 or ps3

[never_waste_a_bullet]

best game ive ever played(single player)- hands down

[Coolmanrico]

Overrated is just a term used by people who don't appreciate something as much as the majority of other people do.

[-MD-]

Uncharted 2 was pretty freakin amazing. I remember there being way too many climbing/platforming sections but that's about the only negative thing I do remember about the game.

[likedamaster]

Stealth mission/gameplay was flawed.

[JonnyBigBoss]

Top 3 game of the generation.

IT IS NOT OVERRATED.

[Nate-Dog]

Uncharted 2 is a great game but is a bit overrated. The fact that almost every single game released on the PS3 now is compared to it is pretty annoying especially when they have nothing in common and are completely different games. As others have said, millions that love UC2 are there to say us that think it's overrated are wrong, but it doesn't mean we are wrong. Just an opinion.

[Malebaria]

Quite the opposite! The industry needs more defining titles like Uncharted 2,Flower,Mass Effect 2 and LBP 2 and stop will all these annual Call of Duty titles in order to evolve. All the praise U2 got was rightfully deserved.

[Rockstar]

added to the growing list of sites that have no idea what they are talking about.
no clicky for you!

Did they play it?

Uncharted 2 and it's predecessor are both amazing games that are not overrated in the least.

[dizzleK]

everyone forgets how barren last year was. besides uc2, odst and batman, what else was there?

overrated? debatable. but had last year been filled with heavy hitters like RDR, mass effect 2, gt5, reach, etc like this year is, i doubt things would have turned out the same.

[mac4u10]

Till this day this game still blows my mind how polished it is in all aspects!!!

[Thoreau]

it is a great game and i hate to type this but the 360 has not seen a game of uncharted 2s caliber this gen. mass effect 2 was close but the combat sequences and the waist high cover boxes were too obvious. i dont get the hate on uc2 but the game looked phenomenal and plays tight. my only gripe is the online noobs of uc2 made the mulitplayer aspect of the game extremely trash. version 1.05 was the best. the high damage and wide grenade radius made the multiplayer so much more fun and if you were smart, you could easily eliminate campers by throwing grenades, but the less skilled players cried, and ND gave them what they wanted. now, even less players play the online aspect of UC2. version 1.05 was heady, skilled and damaging, this version of uc2 multi player rewards the player getting shot in the back.....

[The_Zeitgeist]

I don't see how the cover system is janky. The cover system is silky smooth. Uncharted 2 is one of those rare games that is truly worthy of a perfect 10. You don't have to like it, but you should at least respect it. Thats how I have always felt about the Zelda games. It's not my thing but I understand their brilliance.

[bjornbear]

about a game that came out almost a year ago, and calling it over rated.

im calling the author late to the party, and that is NOT a good thing.

[CaptainPunch]

People are just jealous of Uncharted 2 because it set the bar so high.

[clintos59]

All those that call this game overrated dont even know the meaning of overrated. Its like me saying ive played on XBL but because I like PSN better because its free that makes XBL overrated because I and a few others say its overrated.

Its like me saying halo online multiplayer is overrated, because i think gears of war 2 online is better. Point is my favorite game this next gen is MGS4 but u dont see me saying uncharted 2 is overrated, and its a "FACT" that the reason why i didnt say so is because it has PROVEN itself and reason why? Because its simple, great devs will always deliver & UC2 surpassed everything from the first UC & the gaming industry agrees & is why UC2 has won GOTY09 & has won the most awards ever in the history of gaming. So tell me why is it overrated again?

[Ascalon94]

IMO Uncharted is overrated. Besides the beautiful graphics, its just your average third person shooter with a few explosions here and there. I played the game and this is what I think.

[OSU_Gamer]

I did enjoy UC1 more than 2.

[MysticStrummer]

This guy is either someone with an obvious agenda, or someone who has no business reviewing games. It's one thing to not like a game as much as everyone else, and it's another thing to get specific and list reasons that just make you seem stupid.

[Denethor_II]

You could say the same for The Gears series, or the Halo series.

[PLAYWATCH]

Very few, if any, are better than Uncharted 2, period.
By saying Uncharted 2 is generic, they are essentially shitting on all other games.

[Odin777]

Why does it matter if it is or isn't? I rarely see anything about Crysis or Call of Duty and those two games are the most overrated games I've played this generation.

[IneedWeed]

GTA IV could've been better, but I think it was an overall good game. The engine, graphics, environment, physics, and gameplay was what made the game really fun and new. Hopefully GTA V does it more like GTA San Andreas, where you control gangs and buy properties.

lol UC 2 Overrated? Shit Halo and Gears is overrated, but game is still good. Mario Galaxy 2 is overrated, it got a perfect 10(good game, but not perfect).
Red Dead Redemption deserves to get 9.5+ it was really better than GTA IV IMO.

[TomDaSpartan]

the Uncharted games. I do most of my gaming on Xbox 360, but I do own a PS3 in which I play games such as Uncharted 1 & 2, God of War 3, LBP, Warhawk. Anyway, Uncharted 2 is the best PS3 game that I have played hands down, my opinion of course. It is not overrated, enjoyed every single minute of it and if I were any good at the multiplayer would still be playing it today.

[Prcko]

uncharted best game ever !

[skullmcrex]

Uncharted 2 was a good enough single player experience however the multiplayer features lacked anything innovative, and frankly left me bored. I don't care about awards and other people's opinions, this is mine, deal with it the same way I do.

*I think the dwindling numbers of people still playing U2 online shows that many people hold a similar opinion to me.

[silvacrest]

no pathetic article 8 months after the game is out is gonna change that

the list of awards should be enough for any sane person but some worthless site just had to get some hits, they wont be getting any from me

[jneul]

it's only overrated if you love xbox so much your blind to the nonstop awards uncharted 2 got, games dont get free awards you know they acually have to earn them, fanboys are just jealous because their console has not had any games given lots of awards like uncharted 2 in years....
I still play on uncharted 2 and 1 every now and again it's just so special, it deserves every sale and every award it deserves respect from every gamer.. they are nothing short of epic masterpieces and games like them don't come very often.

[xtremexx]

Uncharted 2 Great- Just Stick With You Opinion

[skullmcrex]

Fanboys are in the air, everywhere and everysound

[Trroy]

So... in order to be great, a game must innovate in some way the user finds blatantly palpable? Uncharted 2 probably innovated in tons of ways technologically to look, and play, as good as it did. Because this isn't directly perceived, like gameplay innovations are, doesn't stop it from being innovative.

On top of that, if user-palpable innovation was what really drove greatness in any industry, we'd never respect things like orchestral performances, plays, great sports teams, etc. -- we'd only respect composers, playwrights, and innovative coaches. Performance art is two-fold -- innovation AND performance.

If Uncharted 2 is the greatest performance we've seen this generation, then it deserves some serious merit. If it doesn't innovate, simply in terms of palpable gameplay -- but simply perfects it.. I don't think you can really mark it down too much for that. Who is to say that its technological innovations didn't drive the excellent cinematic and gameplay quality, in any case?

[djfullshred]

Usually I read the articles before commenting on them, but this was long & I admit only skimming, and then quitting...

So my comment is that this game is in the "already played" bin for most people. It seems strange we keep seeing long dissertations about why it is supposedly not that great. It's not very topical anymore. Although making claims like this on highly acclaimed games does charge people up into silly arguments and get hit counts I suppose.

[shogun101]

The author of this flamebait article can eat a bowl of dicks.

[ForROME]

This isnt news, the games single player is fantastic in a place of its own, single player there isnt a better exp around, multi and reply, thats when it falls short

after 2 play throughs I cant think of a time I say I want to play UC2

PS3 still has a very Single Player Exp feel to it, 360 was built ground up for community and it shows

[Prcko]

uncharted rocks!

[lex-1020]

You can say its overrated and it just takes from other games, but how many games use 3rd person shooting. Quite a few, now how many games use 3rd person shooting plus vertical platforming. None. How many games carry that over to multiplayer? None. As a novelist myself i realize how difficult it is to write a full story. Very few games, especially shooters have a story as good as Uncharted 2.

[PS360PCROCKS]

"However, their is absolutely nothing in the game to differentiate grabable ledges from background scenery."

hmm i guess red and blue bricks are differentiating enough? What a dumbass

[djfullshred]

haha, no doubt. The grabable ledges almost glow in the dark they are so obvious. Perhaps the author has some vision issues, or a really bad TV set.

[PS360PCROCKS]

Haha ya no shit. Some peoples hate for stuff is so funny because most of it stems from their own stupidity!