570°
9.5

Meristation: Uncharted 2 Review

Uncharted 2 has no rival on the PS3. There's no other game, despite Killzone 2 on the visuals, with the same level of quality as Naughty Dog's newest game. The rhythm of the game is fast-paced and action-packed, and includes some fun, well-thought-out dialogue. The game is almost perfect in every stage, and it has online coop and deathmatch; there's no doubt that it's one of the top three games for the PS3, and one of the five best games of this year. [via Metacritic]

Read Full Story >>
translate.google.com
Cyrax_875314d ago (Edited 5314d ago )

currently sitting on 97 average lol.

edit: @ nForce

lmao, I know. since when is 12-13 hours short? There's always something to nitpick.

JRaptor5314d ago

Yeah, I'm surprised that OPM UK still isn't up..even still, its doing well at 97

Tomonobu Itagaki5314d ago

Be patient, Eurogamer and Edge still didn't published their review, it still have chances to drop to 80-82.

Cwalat5314d ago

Uncharted will hopefully score high on Metacritic, personally i hope it scores above 9.8, so it becomes historical moment for gaming industry. It's what Naughtygod deserves and hopefully will result in shi**load of sales.

I won't judge any reviews til i play the game myself. Only then will it become clear who actually is biased or not.

jammy_705314d ago (Edited 5314d ago )

so gllllaaaaadd i have a pppsss33!!!!!!!

isat 97 now... but surly it should be 98?

DAVID BRENT5314d ago

why with ps3 games people make up ridiculous negatives to hide the fact that cant find any just so not to give a ps3 game a perfect score?

mal_tez925314d ago

The fact that GTA4 has a 98 is proof enough that they mean nothing. I mean I've seen overrated games before but that REALLY doesnt deserve it.

I'm pretty sure Uncharted 2 does deserve the scores it is getting because Drake's Fortune is the closes't thing to 100/100 perfection that exists in gaming.

Syronicus5314d ago

The reasons for the minus .5 point are pathetic. Sorry, but they seem to have simply tried to justify their reasons for not wanting to give the game the perfect score it deserved.

heroicjanitor5314d ago

Action games are rarely as long as uncharted 2, that's even without forgetting the multiplayer

starvinbull5314d ago

Edge are on a bit of a roll as far as PS3 reviews go this generation. They will have no reason to mark this game down but then again they have found reasons to do so in the past with other games.
If a PS3 game isn't as innovative and fun as LBP it doesn't stand much of a chance of a fair review in Edge. Perhaps Uncharted 2 will be just a bit too good for them to mark it down.

A game literally has to be getting game of the year awards to be taken seriously on the PS3 in Edge, how did they arrive at that policy?

Christopher5314d ago

Most are reporting 12-15 hours. Most single-player games today aren't able to get that level of play through even with hunting for hidden flags/clues/whatever and forcing you to spend time backtracking over area you've already covered.

Just finished my first time through Batman AA and it took me only a few hours, would have taken a lot less without looking for the Riddler items and the need to backtrack once I had all the bat gadgets for getting to them in each location. Regardless, the game wasn't too short for what it was and is still a great game (9/10 for me).

So, very confused why anyone would complain about 12-15 hours on a single-player element of the game that also has multiplayer attached to it.

Face Palm5314d ago (Edited 5314d ago )

Apparently a 13 hour PS3 game is short but an 6-8 hour 360 game (just about EVERY 360 game) is just fine :/

Basically, they gave docked it 0.5 points for being longer than most games...

Seems similar to how IGN took 0.5 points off of U2 for it not explaining stealth that great... Yeah, that's really worth docking half a point for...

SnuggleBandit5313d ago

its pretty ridiculous that ps3 exclusives have to do EVERYTHING right and are nitpicked to death when we know that if it was a multiplat game that these miniscule points would just be ignored

ShadowCK5313d ago

Why is everyone boasting about the 97% on Metacritic for Uncharted 2? It's based off three reviews and it's definitely not going to last. Gears of war 2 has the same score when it was first released and I bet you that GameSpot, Edge and GameTrailers will shoot Uncharted 2 down.

You may argue there is four reviews on Metacritic but I don't count the PlayStation Magazine because they automatically give every PlayStation exclusive a 10/10 with no good reasons whatsoever. How it's on Metacritic is outstanding.

TheDeadMetalhead5313d ago

12-13 hours is too short, but Halo 3: ODST's 6-hour campaign and rehashed multiplayer is perfectly respectable? Talk about a double-standard. >.>

Day one. =D

Sarcasm5313d ago

"but I don't count the PlayStation Magazine because they automatically give every PlayStation exclusive a 10/10 with no good reasons whatsoever."

Uhhh don't you look silly...

OPM Review Scores:

SOCOM Confrontation: 7/10
Resistance 2: 8/10
Motorstorm PR: 6/10
Infamous: 8/10
Warhawk: 6.5/10
Heavenly Sword: 8/10
Lair: 5/10
Motorstorm 1: 8.5/10
Time Crisis 4: 8/10
Uncharted 1: 8/10
R&C Future: 9.5/10

WOWW... those are ALLL 10s!!!

thesummerofgeorge5313d ago

but especially an action game that is so groundbreaking and spectacular in every other way, it can't be like 25+ hours, for the type of game it is and for how rich every other aspect is, 12-13 hours is not only adequate, it's impressive.

Perfect scores are the hardest to get when the game actually deserves it. U:2 is only being nitpicked because it is so outstanding.

TheReaper425313d ago

heck if i can get an action movie that lasts 13 hours.. da damn~

+ Show (14) more repliesLast reply 5313d ago
yoghurt5314d ago

great score, but I STILL don't understand this:

worst
- Story Mode which is short (approx. 12-13 hours)

since when is that short......

nobody minds a 9.5, but give it a real reason!

mastiffchild5314d ago

I know. That's longer than most action games I've played recently and a very acceptable length when you consider it's longer than the first game AND on top they added brilliant MP.

Unless they thought it was that amazing they never wanted it to end and knocked off.5 to spite ND for not giving them more! Or they mostook it for an RPG?

What did Meristation think of ODST or COD4's length in SP?(honest question as IIRC they're a pretty tough marking lot)

jjohan355313d ago

I completely agree with Mastiffchild. Everyone forgives ODST's and COD's short campaigns, while a 12 hour campaign for Uncharted 2 is considered too short?

cLiCK_sLiCK95313d ago

You guys have understand that most reviewers must have a "GOOD" and "BAD" comments on their actual review. For this reason, they post stupid comments like " Naughty God has to rest" and "Ummmmm Short campaign??" comments because there just really isnt anything BAD about this particular game. And commenting NONE on "BAD" wont sound so professional imo.

Because of the way they reviewed this game, it clearly deserves a 10 imo. By saying saying that Naughty Dog is going on a vacation doest justify .5 points taken away.

Pssh. And ppl once told that there is no such thing as a perfect game...

theEnemy5313d ago

maybe Uncharted 2 is so good that they are forced to invent cons.

pathetic. really..

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5313d ago
nForce5314d ago (Edited 5314d ago )

-History mode is short (12-13h aprox.)
-Naughty Dog has to rest instead of putting already to do another game

Pathetic.

Meristation never gives a perfect puntuation to the exclusives ps3 games. (MGS4 & LBP only).

Sheddi5314d ago

I havent clicked on the link but this one...
"-Naughty Dog has to rest instead of putting already to do another game"
really? did they really write that?

jjohan355313d ago

Am I the only one who is a bit concerned that Naughty Dog decided to include revenge attribute to the online play? (also known as martyrdom). It pretty much makes melee kills obsolete.

El Botto5314d ago (Edited 5314d ago )

today it still stands as a testimony of the true power of the PS3. There is no game on the betabox360 that comes close to rivalling it.

And now Uncharted 2 has arrived. Its sheer superiority will never be surpassed by the flopbox.

Uncharted 2 blows away all the crap thats on the 360.

Shane Kim5314d ago

Can't argue with that.

Unrivaled 2 stands on a 97 on meta (it's only 5 reviews but still) while Gaylo 3: Go Go power rangeeeeeeeers, dooo dooo dooooo doodoooo, Go Go power rangeeeeeeers, mighty morphin power raaaaangeeeeeeeeeeeeers, is on 85.

AliTheBrit5314d ago

Although Uncharted graphics where and still are awesome, I have to Disagree.

I Think that Gears of War 2 Easily Matches and in many aspects, out-performs Uncharted 1 Graphics Wise

But thats just my Humble Opinion, Then Again I'm willing to bet you have only Played Uncharted
While I have played both.

El Botto5314d ago

Gears 2 uses bloom to hide the fact that every object and character in gears 2 is low res. Hell, Drake's hair alone has more polygons than an entire level of gears 2.

So dont lie, bot.

Shane, I agree. Let us not forget that 85 metacritic on XBOX standard is in reality only worth a 6.5 if Halo ODST came to the PS3.

So a 9.5 for Uncharted 2 would be equal to a 13/10 on XBOX 360.

Nelson M5314d ago

You Can Take Your Humble Opinion
Write it Down on a Sheet of Toilet paper
Pass it Over to me
And i'll Wipe my Ass with it
Thy Silly little BoT

ReviewsArePolitics5313d ago

That his opinion is humble. In fact, so humble, to the point of ignorance and worthlessness.

Anyway, the lighting, the colors, the AI, the interactivity, the polygon count, the textures, the soundtrack, the animation, the gameplay and the fun are on another level, Gears can't really compete. Objectively, the polygon count is twice as high per character, and the textures are twice as detailed.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 5313d ago
Ravage275314d ago

Maybe all PS3-exclusives are expected to set the new standard for the industry, which they ALWAYS do. Then again what were they expecting?

95/100 is a very good score considering Meristation don't hand out 9s that often.

Show all comments (80)
90°

Active Quest Episode 100: Our Favorite Games of All Time

Chris, Joseph, and Josh celebrate Active Quest’s 100th episode by discussing their favorite games of all time.

Read Full Story >>
activequestpodcast.com
140°

Recharting Uncharted 2: Among Thieves – Retrospective Review

Nevada Dru from Bits & Pieces revisits Uncharted 2: Among Thieves to see if this legendary game has stood the test of time.

Read Full Story >>
bitsandpieces.games
Abnor_Mal1444d ago

Currently playing Drakes Fortune on crushing, next will be to replay Among Thieves, but I'm sure it still holds up today.

P_Bomb1444d ago (Edited 1444d ago )

Recently re-platinumed 1-3. Uncharted 2 aged better than I even expected. I enjoyed it more now than I did a decade ago. It’s more polished than 1, tighter than 3 and Yemen in 3 was gorgeous. Shambhala out-prettied Ubar though. 60fps w higher res’ made for a damn good rerun.

Abnor_Mal1443d ago

Question: When you say Uncharted2 aged better than expected, are you talking about the original PS3 game or the remastered collection on PS4. I ask because I think that a remastered version of the game would look and play better than the original.

I doubt that the original ran at 60 frames, how many years old is the remastered collection anyway.

I need to replay the original trilogy along with the collection, not a fan of the collection trophy of beating levels in a set time and don't think the originals required that for platinum.

P_Bomb1443d ago (Edited 1443d ago )

@abnor_mal
It’s true that the remasters have upped the resolution and given it 60fps, but the base game is the same. The art design and base textures/physics/ animations are the same yet still look contemporary. More-so than UC1 which isn’t as tight, or UC3 in some cases which I found a bit clunky in close quarters.

UC2 level design was a great evolution in bringing the verticality from the jungle into rural/urban settings while maintaining smooth animation transitions. Drake still moves better than the ginger in Star Wars Jedi. Outdoor areas are better lit.

UC2 also has more action and better pacing imo, which helps when replaying a game 10 years later. Kept me engaged.

You don’t need to time trial for platinum. They stuck the speedrun trophies in a seperate extended dlc category so have no fear.

MadLad1444d ago

I thought the originals were good, but not great. I understand that puts me in the minority here. That said, Uncharted 4 was freaking fantastic.

Profchaos1444d ago (Edited 1444d ago )

Yeah I understand the hate for 4 prior to playing it I was firmly against it and felt like 3 wrapped things up already but now after playing it I think it was the best in the franchise.

Now I look back at two and I feel like I'm playing an on the rails shooter everything is so tightly scripted including the infamous train scene you simply can't make a mistake

Rimeskeem1444d ago

I think Uncharted 2 is a lot like AC2. Both games took the idea and basically improved it in every single way.

Movefasta19931443d ago

Uc2, AC2,Halo2, Soul calibur 2, Killzone 2, Infamous 2 , Dishonored 2 and a few more. The only negative thing I have against uc2, and imo it annoyed me,are the blue apes, uncharted 1 handled the super natural far better.

90°

15 Best Action Set Pieces in the Uncharted Series

Cultured Vultures: What's your favourite moment from the Uncharted franchise? Here are 15 that got our blood pumping.

Read Full Story >>
culturedvultures.com
Imalwaysright1479d ago

My favorite is the building collapsing on Uncharted 2.

goldwyncq1479d ago

The entire final chapter of The Lost Legacy is the best setpiece in the series and it wasn't even mentioned.