I really dug the atmosphere that RDR gave off. It's not supposed to be like GTA with tons and tons of people running around every inch of the map. I think they did a great job.

I dont want to see another one
They did such a brilliant job on red dead that if they were to do it again would be duplicative. If they are going to do anything, create a new world. create an new place...don't do it over again. Really looking forward to LA Noir. Also, if they were to do it again, I would like to see it maybe later in the US history. Maybe the son of John's Son--distant relative..so that we could see how some of the things have changed...or visit Armadillo when it is a ghost town...etc. If they do it again, they need to make some major changes...liven up the world a bit more...it is an incredible feat, but there needs to be something to alter the landscape.

I would like to see Red Dead Redemption articles not appearing in the PC section since there is no RDR on the PC but I get the feeling it isn't going to happen.

How would it be 2? That's like saying "What we expect from Elder Scrolls: Oblivion 2". Stupid. Also, hopefully they just make a new IP but I know that's wishful thinking. Can be the same style but why is it so much to ask for a new setting and theme? One game is plenty for the wild west, considering the setting was pretty bland and empty. I don't think I would get another game like that.