Comments (30)
kalkano  +   270d ago
Kefka is an antagonist, not a protagonist.
ObstructedViewsNet  +   270d ago
I thought I corrected that thank you for letting me know I'll fix it immediately
Menech  +   270d ago
Is Disgaea really a JRPG? I have only played 3, and it definitely falls into the strategy games camp from my prospective.
Baka-akaB  +   270d ago
Yeah Disgaea is a SRPG/tactical rpg actually . So is fire Emblem . And if you're going to list some i'd go with Tactics Ogre or Final fantasy tactics over disgaea personally .

Decent enough list but i'd remove "traditional" titles such as Vesperia , Lost odyssey , Ni no Kuni or even Star ocean 3 ... for as good if not better experiences that are way more unique , such as any persona games , Shadow Hearts 1-2 , Shin megami tensei 3 Nocturne , Valkyrie Profile 1-2 or any main Suikoden (minus the horrible 4)
#1.1.2 (Edited 270d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(8) | Report
Menech  +   270d ago
Suikoden 2 is the best Suikoden game, the others aren't even close, although I did enjoy 5.

Most fans consider Star Ocean 2 the best in the series also, I count myself among them.
kalkano  +   270d ago
@Menech:

Some JRPGs are Strategy RPGs. See my avatar.
marilyn11young   270d ago | Spam
Kamuymintar  +   270d ago
I want to add Valkyrie Profile to the list instead of recent games.

And I love these Japan-exclusive and unknown (even for the Japanese) masterpieces of JRPGs in 1990's:

- Tenshi No Uta II: Datenshi No Sentaku
- Illusion City
- Linda Cube (aka Linda Cube again)
- Ore No Shikabane o Koeteyuke
Crazay  +   270d ago
I'd put Lunar 1 and 2 in there as well as the original Suikoden.
Wigriff  +   270d ago
And Grandia 2.
khellendros1  +   270d ago
So many people who started out with FF7 missed on what I think is the best Final fantasy in 6. Kefka is a lunatic, lol.
kalkano  +   270d ago
I played them both, and in order. It's hard for me to pick which one I like more. But, I usually do go for 7, by a hair.
ObstructedViewsNet  +   270d ago
They are both such great games it really is hard to decide between them.
zippycup  +   270d ago
FF6 is one of my top rpg's

dragon warrior also holds a place at the top
klecser  +   270d ago
Fire Emblem and Disgaea are not JRPGs. They're SRPGs.

Sheesh, its like anything that is made in Japan and has CHARACTERS in it gets labelled a JRPG.
kalkano  +   270d ago
JRPG and turn-based are not synonymous. JRPGs can be turn-based, strategy, or action. Now, I don't consider games like Dark Souls to be JRPGs. But, that's because they are trying to emulate WRPGs, and pretty much are WRPGs.
klecser  +   270d ago
The one thing you have right is that gamers disagree. I think you are in the minority with your definitions.

People that actually play strategy RPGs do not lump them in with JRPGs.
kalkano  +   267d ago
My avatar is from a JRPG, that is also a strategy RPG. Shining Force 3 is one of my favorite games, ever. So, I do play them. I don't know how anyone can not consider it a JRPG.
Hicken  +   270d ago
An SRPG can still be a JRPG.
Snookies12  +   270d ago
If the game is an RPG that comes from Japan or has a decidedly Japanese style, it's a JRPG. Regardless of whether it's turn based, action, or strategy.
#4.4 (Edited 270d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Misaka_x_Touma  +   264d ago
JRPG = Japanese RPG that plays and has Anime Like Characters.
#4.5 (Edited 264d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
KingofGambling  +   270d ago
Suikoden II.
JeepGamer  +   270d ago
"4: Final Fantasy VII

Wait, what? He didn’t put Final Fantasy VII at number one! How could he? "

No, he's got this wrong.

That game doesn't belong on the list at all.
TronEOL  +   270d ago
And clearly, you don't know video games.

I'm guessing your top JRPG list probably only includes completely obscure and poorly received JRPG's because that's what cool kids do.
JeepGamer  +   270d ago
First of all, I'm old. Old enough that I played Final Fantasy when it was a new game. To say that I've played a lot of JRPGs would be a vast understatement.

You will notice that I singled out that game from his list for criticism without being critical of the entire list. That would be because it's a fairly broad spectrum of what's what in JRPGs, and most of those games are actually quite good.

FF7 was crap. The story was crap. The characters were crap. The game play was crap. The graphics were crap except for the FMV sequences which were pretty good in the day it was made.

My top favorite RPG? I've always liked Final Fantasy 4 out of the FF series best but FF6 was up there too. The only 'obscure' RPG I think is fantastic and never gets the place it deserves on these lists is Dark Cloud 2.
DVAcme  +   270d ago
@TronEOL Damn right, Dark Cloud 2 is an unsung gem. It's actually amazing how many Level-5 RPGs get overlooked when they're such an excellent game JRPG developer. Rogue Galaxy, Dark Cloud 2, Jeanne d'Arc, and even Ni No Kuni are amazing games that are massively overlooked.
False-Patriot  +   270d ago
Where is Valkyria Chronicles, Xenosaga and Chrono Cross?
DVAcme  +   270d ago
-Valkyria Chronicles. One of the most heartfelt, beautiful RPGs ever made.
-Rogue Galaxy. SERIOUSLY underrated, with lots of charming characters, a rock-solid real-time battle system, loads of item crafting and secrets to find, Chrono trigger-style combination attacks and awesome voice-acting.
Son_Lee  +   270d ago
Legend of Legaia: Never gets the recognition it deserves.

Legend of Dragoon: More popular, but still never credited enough.

Illusion of Gaia: If you can find it, play it!

Phantasy Star II: The game that got me into RPGs.
Misaka_x_Touma  +   264d ago
Xenoblade Chronicles
Final Fantasy VIII
Tales of the Abyss PS2 or 3DS
Radiant Historia
Fire Emblem Awakening
Chrono Trigger DS
Golden Sun
Skies of Arcadia
Arc Rise Fantasia

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember