Comments (30)
claud3  +   424d ago
Then that is your choice
retrozoid  +   424d ago
Always difficult to chose, think saints row edges it on the fun factor
dvewlsh  +   424d ago
I really, really liked SR2 just for how fun and ridiculous it was. The story was kind of whatever, but I had a lot of fun just causing mayhem in it. I thought that in SR3 they kind of tried to appeal to that a bit too much, which made it feel less fun.
Hazmat13  +   424d ago
eh get both. no big deal. haha
ifritAlkhemyst  +   424d ago
Saints Row series > GTA IV

GTA III, VC, & SA >> Saints Row series

Hell, Bully, a game built exclusively on mini games, is better than the Saints Row series.
SilentNegotiator  +   424d ago
Saints Row 2 > SA > Saints Row 1 and 3

But Bully > Saints Row series? Heck no.
TheEnigma313  +   424d ago
Saints row is a bit too silly for my tastes. Gta 5 looks sick.
mafiahajeri  +   424d ago
To each his own, but Im baffled how anyone can prefer that crappy game SR over GTA, baffled...

SR is feels like a thrown together mess, heck there next game was meant to be DLC, lol no comparison...
MiasmaDodo  +   424d ago
I love Both.

In my gaming sessions GTA4 is NY (obviously)
and Saints Row 2 feels like Texas to me. LoL

they are both fun, and I am glad they are different.
cyguration  +   424d ago
I'm still playing GTA IV and Saints Row 2.

I uninstalled Saints Row: The Third after beating it since there was nothing to do.

It looks like SRIV will be closer to SR:TR than it will be SR2, and for that reason it's hard for me to say that Saints Row as a series is better when only one of their games was as good as the GTA series.
MestreRothN4G  +   424d ago
While I love both SR and GTA, I think you're right.
But Saints Row is growing, getting its own identity, which began clearly as a GTA ripoff, evolving to something completely nonsense and fun. Quite the opposite of GTA IV.

With GTA V being GTA again and SR4 moving towards the complete BS area, I think we shouldn't even compare the games more than Sleeping against Watch Dogs.
retrozoid  +   424d ago
Saints row is easy to get into for me compared to GTA
Sketchy_Galore  +   424d ago
GTA4 was unbelievably repetitive and could have been cut down by half of its playtime without losing anything but I still would much rather play it again than any Saints row, especially 3. There's only so much you can laugh at a giant rubber penis and a man in a silly costume before you start noticing the lazy, poorly made game underneath. I'll take a weighty, low speed chase through a living breathing city over a high speed rocket dildo bike chase through a dead feeling map with no actual immersion factor whatsoever.
cyguration  +   424d ago
Yeah I agree.

I've really learned to appreciate and love the car chases in GTA IV now, especially with custom vehicles from other games.

I don't think I've ever had a meaningful car chase in Saints Row: The Third. It's so sad how shallow that game was after you unlocked all the basic stuff.
retrozoid  +   424d ago
The dildo was the funniest thing in the game for me lol
CarnageXB  +   424d ago
Ill just put this here. I haven't finished a single GTA campaign. I have finished the Saints Row 2 campaign twice. I have finished Saints Row the Third campaign 1 and a 1/2 times. Saints Row 2 was the best. Saints Row the Third was good but it took away alot. In Saints Row 2 I loved fight club, the extensive highway system, the airport, the extensive car customization, the good story dlc, and The awesome easter eggs out in the ocean and on the land. In SR3 I liked the upgradable hangouts, the the zombies, cool vehicles, the character customization, and most of the story.

Stilwater>Steelport

But I am looking forward to GTA 5. Especially Online.
#13 (Edited 424d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
H4zZz4  +   424d ago
Saints row 2 was very good but I feel that saints 3 was a bit too over the top.
tigertron  +   424d ago
I think SR3 was waaaay better than GTAIV. I can have fun on there, do crazy stuff like kill zombies with Burt Reynolds whilst dressed as a toilet. You can't do that in GTAIV.
cyguration  +   424d ago
Yes you can do that in GTA IV

http://www.youtube.com/watc...
STK026  +   424d ago
I loved GTA 3 and Vice City, I however didn't like San Andreas as much, as, while the gameplay was great, I didn't enjoy the story as much, and by then, was getting tired of the awkward controls of the GTA series. When Saints Row came out, it was buggy, the story was forgettable, the graphics weren't that good for a next-gen game, the soundtrack was pretty bad, but it had great shooting controls, and that's all it needed to win me over.

Then came GTA4, which simply bored me. Saints Row 2 and 3 were awesome, for me anyway. And the co-op aspect was very nice.

I'll be buying both Saints Row 4 and GTA5 at launch, as while they are similar, they are still very different from each other, and I do believe there's at least enough space in the gaming world, for the 2 franchises to co-exist.
retrozoid  +   424d ago
I'd imagine both will cause a stir, we gamers win either way
The_Truth_24_7  +   424d ago
SR series >>> GTA series. The truth has been spoken.
RGDubz  +   424d ago
Rockstar fan boys & casual gamers are the only ones I've ever heard say GTA IV was good, when we all know it is by far the worst GTA of the series.

As far as Saints Row goes, SR2 was the closest thing weve had to a GTA: San Andreas this-gen so far.

Go to the prison in GTA IV, it's completely empty.. Now go to the Prison in Saints Row 2, It's full of guards & prisoners.. Which world would you rather play in? Let's face it, only a blind Rockstar fan boy would still say GTA IV's world.

Hypocrites will say "well the graphics are better", yet they weren't playing Driver 3 & 4 last-gen when they had the much, much better graphics over the GTA titles.. To them last-gen was about gameplay and now apparently this-gen is about graphics, because whatever Rockstar does better is all the blind fan boys want to focus on.
#19 (Edited 424d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
RavageX  +   424d ago
That was in SR2 though. 3 was complete rubbish. Everything that made 2 great(mainly for me it was the fact the city had life) is gone.

GTA4 was incredibly boring for me. I enjoyed it but not in the manner I enjoyed the previous games in the series, and I felt that was a problem.

Instead of taking SR4 back to the series roots, they've turned SR3's expansion into a full blown game(supposedly), so I already know I will be disappointed.
Goro  +   424d ago
Overall i prefer GTA but i do think SR2 + 3 were better than GTA4...
iceman06  +   424d ago
I agree. I did enjoy the world of GTA4, but the mission were just really kind of bland after a couple of hours. The one thing that Saints Row does well is to disguise their mission types behind the over-the-top narrative. That being said. I am REALLY looking forward to GTA 5. Seems like a return to the roots of the game, serious...but with a chaotically crazy undertone.
PersonMan  +   424d ago
Saints Row is not fun to me. It's too arcade-like and ridiculous.

GTA IV is mature and the physics are really fun to mess with.
_FantasmA_  +   424d ago
You guys can thumb me down all you want but the only GTA that was a masterpiece was Vice City. 3 was okay but only towards the end when you could travel outside the first island. San Andread was just graphically ugly and was the same crap over and over again and was really racist. Didn't care for 4. Saints Row is lame too, but I did play the first one for a few days before I got bored with it. Sleeping Dogs was more mature, and had a tightly scripted main storyline. Hopefully we get a Sleeping Dogs 2.
#22 (Edited 424d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
RGDubz  +   424d ago
I like features from Vice City but I disliked it the most out of the PS2 GTA's, I would much rather play the real Scarface game instead of that fake "Scarface" game, I also dislike how flat the map was.. It was kinda weak overall, I played GTA 3 way more til San Andreas dropped.

#1 GTA: San Andreas
#2 GTA 3
#3 GTA: Vice City

At least for me.

Also, Sleeping Dogs is great & I'd bet we'll be seeing a 2nd game.
#22.1 (Edited 424d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
_FantasmA_  +   423d ago
That's why I liked it. It felt like Scarface more than the Scarface game, but all the Scarface tracks had already been used in 3. San Andreas was the worst for me. I played a few missions and then threw it in a shoebox. Its somewhere around my house but I'll never play it. You can only beat up so many hookers before a game gets old.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember